| Player | Team | POS | Analysis |
| Allen Iverson | Pistons | G | Awfully quiet. Was all his strength in the braids? |
| Dwyane Wade | Heat | G | Heat's hoping he got all the 3s out of his system. |
| LeBron James | Cavaliers | F | Got a little too caught up in The Show at times. |
| Kevin Garnett | Celtics | F | Best player on woeful East shot 5-of-5, played D. |
| Dwight Howard | Magic | C | Shot over backboard had East bench in stitches. |
| Joe Johnson | Hawks | G | How do you play 22 min. and not score? |
| Ray Allen | Celtics | G | Better delivery on Russell's cake than shot (4-10). |
| Danny Granger | Pacers | F | Went 11 minutes on bum knee, with one bucket. |
| Paul Pierce | Celtics | F | Screw it. I'm the Finals MVP, and I'm shooting. |
| Mo Williams | Cavs | G | Quietly had a strong night with 12/5 in 17 min. |
| Devin Harris | Nets | G | Had game-worst -31 +/- in rough ASG debut. |
| Rashard Lewis | Magic | F | Uh, change in plans: You'll guard Shaquille O'Neal. |
| Mike Brown | Cavs | Had no answer up front. Not sure there was one. |
 |
ESPN Insider John Hollinger's grade: D+ |
