| 
 | 
 | 
 
 
| 1999 | 
Denver 34, Atlanta 19 | 
Miami | 
 
 
| 1998 | 
Denver 31, Green Bay 24 | 
San Diego | 
 
 
| 1997 | 
Green Bay 35, New England 21 | 
New Orleans | 
 
 
| 1996 | 
Dallas 27, Pittsburgh 17 | 
Tempe, Ariz.  | 
 
 
| 1995 | 
San Francisco 49, San Diego 26 | 
Miami | 
 
 
| 1994 | 
Dallas 30, Buffalo 13 | 
Atlanta | 
 
 
| 1993 | 
Dallas 52, Buffalo 17 | 
Pasadena, Calif. | 
 
 
| 1992 | 
Washington 37, Buffalo 24 | 
Minneapolis | 
 
 
| 1991 | 
New York Giants 20, Buffalo 19 | 
Tampa, Fla. | 
 
 
| 1990 | 
San Francisco 55, Denver 10 | 
New Orleans | 
 
 
| 1989 | 
San Francisco 20, Cincinnati 16 | 
Miami | 
 
 
| 1988 | 
Washington 42, Denver 10 | 
San Diego | 
 
 
| 1987 | 
New York Giants 39, Denver 20 | 
Pasadena, Calif. | 
 
 
| 1986 | 
Chicago 46, New England 10 | 
New Orleans | 
 
 
| 1985 | 
San Francisco 38, Miami 16 | 
Stanford, Calif. | 
 
 
| 1984 | 
L.A. Raiders 38, Washington 9 | 
Tampa, Fla. | 
 
 
| 1983 | 
Washington 27, Miami 17 | 
Pasadena, Calif. | 
 
 
| 1982 | 
San Francisco 26, Cincinnati 21 | 
Pontiac, Mich. | 
 
 
| 1981 | 
Oakland 27, Philadelphia 10 | 
New Orleans | 
 
 
| 1980 | 
Pittsburgh 31, L.A. Rams 19 | 
Pasadena, Calif. | 
 
 
| 1979 | 
Pittsburgh 35, Dallas 31 | 
Miami | 
 
 
| 1978 | 
Dallas 27, Denver 10 | 
New Orleans | 
 
 
| 1977 | 
Oakland 32, Minnesota 14 | 
Pasadena, Calif. | 
 
 
| 1976 | 
Pittsburgh 21, Dallas 17 | 
Miami | 
 
 
| 1975 | 
Pittsburgh 16, Minnesota 6 | 
New Orleans | 
 
 
| 1974 | 
Miami 24, Minnesota 7 | 
Houston | 
 
 
| 1973 | 
Miami 14, Washington 7 | 
Los Angeles | 
 
 
| 1972 | 
Dallas 24, Miami 3 | 
New Orleans | 
 
 
| 1971 | 
Baltimore 16, Dallas 13 | 
Miami | 
 
 
| 1970 | 
Kansas City 23, Minnesota 7 | 
New Orleans | 
 
 
| 1969 | 
New York Jets 16, Baltimore 7 | 
Miami | 
 
 
| 1968 | 
Green Bay 33, Oakland 14 | 
Miami | 
 
 
| 1967 | 
Green Bay 35, Kansas City 10 | 
Los Angeles | 
 
  
 
 |