M College BB
Scores/Schedules
Rankings
Standings
Statistics
Transactions
Injuries
Weekly lineup
Teams
Recruiting
 Sunday, October 10
Chartered planes help out-of-the-way schools
 
By Andy Katz
Special to ESPN.com

 When he was recruiting J.R. Henderson six years ago, Jim Harrick wanted to get to Henderson's high school practice in Bakersfield, Calif., but he couldn't miss a UCLA workout.

"If we had had a school jet, he could have been there for a 7 p.m. workout on a Tuesday night right after our practice," former UCLA assistant Mark Gottfried said of the recruitment of Henderson when Harrick was the Bruins' head coach. "That would have been a tremendous advantage."

Instead, Harrick and Gottfried had to wait until a later date to make the nearly 90-minute drive from Westwood to Bakersfield. As ironic it may sound for a school as centrally located as UCLA, that's the reality of a program in a major city that doesn't use chartered or university-owned aircraft for recruiting.

Quin Snyder
Quin Snyder and Missouri self-reported their potential NCAA violation.
"In L.A., there's not a lot of need for one," said Gottfried, now the head coach at Alabama. "You can get from LAX (Los Angeles International Airport) to anywhere commercially. It's less convenient for places like Tuscaloosa (Ala.), Auburn (Ala.) or Starkville (Miss.)."

Add Manhattan, Kan., Fayetteville, Ark., Columbia, Mo., and, even at times, Lexington, Ky., to that list. But should it be allowed? Coaches at high-profile schools in college towns without a major airport are scoffing at the idea that the privilege should be taken away because of the recent events involving Missouri.

Last week, Missouri self-reported itself to the NCAA for allowing the mothers of Detroit-area recruits Rickey Paulding and Arthur Johnson to join their sons -- for the price of a commercial ticket estimated at $200 to $300 each -- on their recruiting visit Sept. 17-19. The two potential top-50 recruits committed to Missouri on the trip.

The problem is Missouri broke NCAA bylaw 13.6.2.3.3, which forbids parents from traveling on recruiting visits by noncommercial aircraft. While it doesn't state in that section that parents aren't allowed to be on the trip, it does in bylaw 13.6.2.3.2, which details recruits using a university-owned airplane. Missouri misinterpreted the rule and self-reported the violation.

Earlier this week, the NCAA ruled that the 6-foot-4 Paulding (Detroit Renaissance High) and the 6-9 Johnson (Detroit Pershing) could still attend Missouri. The worst penalty in a case like this would be for the players to be forbidden from attending the school where the violation occurred. Instead, Missouri may get a later, lesser penalty that is unrelated to these two recruits. The mistake in judgment by the staff at Missouri raises the question about the use of chartered airplanes, whether they be university-owned or not.

Is it an advantage for one school to use a chartered plane while another has to wait for a recruit to come through on a small commuter aircraft? The fact that despite the costs, a number of schools that are hard to get to via commercial aircraft regularly use chartered planes shows that it is.

"We have our own plane at Alabama and, yes, it's a tremendous advantage," Gottfried said. "We think it's worth it. If a guy can take you to the Final Four, where it can help your school earn money, yes it's cost-effective. We use it within the state, too. We don't have a major airport near us."

Alabama and a number of other SEC, Big Ten, ACC and Big 12 schools have the resources to combat the drawbacks of being in small college towns. Schools like Washington State don't.

"We had a need for that in Pullman," said former Washington State coach Kelvin Sampson, who is now at Oklahoma. "But we had to make a choice to have a kid fly through Seattle or Spokane and then take a commuter plane here. That's the realities of tough jobs. Having a plane is an advantage that a lot of kids would pay attention to. It evokes a sense of power at certain schools. If you fly a high school kid on a Lear jet, you're going to make a tremendous impression."

But does it make financial sense to fly in one recruit? The cost could run as much as $15,000 or more to charter one flight.

"It's expensive and you've got to have a budget to do it, but it's common practice," Kansas State coach Tom Asbury said. "We can go anywhere to get a kid."

Not exactly. Asbury limits the range of Kansas State's plane. For example, he won't send it west of Denver. A recruit from California has to fly commercially to Denver and then be picked up by the private jet for the trip to Manhattan, Kan.

"It's not cost-effective but it's convenient," Asbury said.

If Kansas State is recruiting a player in Dallas, he could practice with his high school team on Friday, be at Kansas State by dinner Friday night and be back at a reasonable hour on Sunday to complete the allowed 48-hour visit. But it would take the recruit two to three times as much travel time if he had to fly commercially to Kansas City and then on a commuter aircraft to Manhattan.

"You only get 12 (recruits) to bring in anyway," Asbury said. "You're bringing in the kids you really want. If men's basketball had 50 campus visits, we wouldn't use it that many times. But the rules need to be enforced, not curtailed. I don't think they can touch that rule."

The rule allowing the use of a noncommercial or institution's plane hasn't been altered since 1990. If the NCAA truly wants equality among its members, it should get rid of the privilege. If it doesn't care, then the imbalances, which at times become abuses and misinterpretations, will continue.

Regardless, the NCAA seems to be getting softer in the enforcement of its rules. The once-feared enforcement arm handed out a one-scholarship reduction to Virginia after it was determined that a 1996 prospect was provided benefits totaling $14,000. The Cavaliers also had their visits reduced from 12 to nine. Jeff Jones (now a Rhode Island assistant) was the head coach at the time, but current coach Pete Gillen is who has to deal with the penalty. The NCAA clearly has gotten weaker because of a slew of lawsuits. It has never been this vulnerable and the fear factor seems to have faded.

The test cases should be Michigan (alleged payments of $50,000 by a booster to a player) and Minnesota (alleged academic fraud) over the next year. If neither program is hit hard then it might be time to reexamine the NCAA's enforcement criteria.

Expansion fever
Conference USA will decide on expansion Monday in New York. The bottom line is the majority of basketball coaches and athletics directors don't want to become a 14-team league, but they have no say with the school presidents. It's foolish to predict what the presidents will do when they're together in a room.

The options facing the presidents:

1) Add South Florida as a football member;
2) Add East Carolina in all sports (the Pirates already participate in football);
3) Add Texas Christian and Southern Methodist in all sports;
4) Take different combinations of the four schools;
5) Take all of them;
6) Do nothing.

The odds are that South Florida, TCU and SMU will be invited and East Carolina will have to wait its turn. But don't be surprised to see all of them taken to make it a 12-team football conference and 15-team basketball league. If Conference USA does anything to increase the league beyond 12 for either sport, it should be vilified. The WAC proved that a league larger than 12 doesn't work.

Meanwhile, the WAC has called an emergency meeting of its presidents on Oct. 17 to discuss replacing TCU and SMU, if they leave. Regardless, the WAC will look at adding Boise State. If TCU and SMU leave, Utah State and New Mexico State will receive serious consideration. But there are plenty of road blocks. UTEP wants no part of being in a league with its nonconference rival New Mexico State, and Fresno State isn't enamored with adding any more schools from the Big West (which the Bulldogs left in 1992).

Weekly chatter

  • Indiana is still a serious threat to land 6-foot-9 Jared Jeffries from Bloomington, Ind. But the news for this season started out poorly for the Big Ten's former marquee program. Freshmen recruits George Leach, a 6-11 center from Olympic High in Charlotte, N.C., and 6-8 freshman Kei Madison (New Hampton Prep/N.H.) aren't eligible, according to Indiana. Both were expected to add depth to a thin front line.

    The Hoosiers should have enough to compete for an NCAA Tournament berth with wings A.J. Guyton, Michael Lewis, Dane Fife, Antwaan Randle El and a frontcourt of Kirk Haston, Lynn Washington and Larry Richardson. But the fact that Indiana is recruiting ineligible players shows a sense of urgency. Without Madison and Leach, the pressure will be on 6-9 freshman Jeffrey Newton to contribute immediately.

  • The Mountain West Conference is appealing the loss of an automatic berth to the 2000 NCAA Tournament. MWC commissioner Craig Thompson said the appeal will be heard Oct. 18-19 at the NCAA management council meeting. But he's not optimistic the decision will be overturned. The MWC, which was formed by eight former WAC members, lost automatic qualification to every NCAA-sponsored sport in 1999-2000. The ban is only for this season.

  • Marquette picked up a second high-profile commitment in as many weeks when 6-9 Terry Sanders from Hargrave Military Academy (Va.) gave an oral commitment.

  • UNC Charlotte signee Demon Brown didn't qualify and is back at Maine Central Institute. The 49ers could have used the 6-1 point guard to back up Diego Guevara.

  • Brian Chase was expected to compete for the starting point guard spot at Virginia Tech, but the 5-10 freshman is at Hargrave Military (Va.) to earn his eligibility for 2000-01.

  • North Carolina's recruiting could take a hit with assistant Phil Ford on leave after a DWI arrest. Ford had the best name-recognition on the staff.

  • Michigan followed up a commitment from 6-9 Bernard Robinson (New Hampton Prep/N.H.) with 5-9 point guard Avery Queen (Winchendon School/Mass.) to give the Wolverines a needed inside-out combo. Queen is a true point, unlike incoming freshmen guards Jamal Crawford and Kevin Gaines, who are posing as playmakers but are really wings.

  • Oregon State is renegotiating Eddie Payne's contract. Payne was under some heat a year ago after mass defections. But he has recovered better than anyone anticipated with a 7-11 Pac-10 season (13-14 overall). The Beavers were one of the toughest home-court teams in the Pac-10 last season with wins over UCLA, Arizona and Stanford. The Beavers should be a top-six team in the Pac-10 with junior point guard Deaundra Tanner returning along with wing Josh Steinthal, center Jason Heide and wing Ramunas Petraitis, the team's second-, third-, and fourth-leading scorers, respectively. The Beavers also added sleeper Brian Jackson, a high-scoring big-man recruit.

  • UCLA's disclosure that forward Matt Barnes is ineligible for the first semester may cement a starting position for freshman Jason Kapono. The 6-7 Barnes (3.9 ppg, 2.9 rpg) played in 30 of 31 games, including eight starts, as a freshman. Kapono should slide in next to Earl Watson and JaRon Rush, with Dan Gadzuric and Jerome Moiso inside. The sixth man will likely be Ray Young.

    The Bruins weren't that deep, even with Barnes, and will be hurt by his absence right away when they face Gonzaga on Dec. 11, their fourth game of the season. The Bruins should be able to take out Fairfield, Iona and Morgan State, but the Bulldogs will pose depth and matchup problems if the Bruins have to go deep on their bench. Barnes' status will be evaluated after final exams Dec. 13-17. The Bruins play host to DePaul on Dec. 18. Barnes can practice with the Bruins while he tries to regain his eligibility.

  • Poor Lorenzo Romar. His staff has gone through more changes in six months than some do in years. Saint Louis lost Derek Thomas to Minnesota in August. Romar replaced him with former UCLA point guard Cameron Dollar. Now, Romar has to find another assistant to replace Jim Shaw, who left to replace Jason Rabedeaux as an assistant at Oklahoma. Rabedeaux was hired as UTEP's head coach last month. Shaw came from the University of Portland when Romar left Pepperdine for Saint Louis in March.

  • Kentucky has unofficially been told that the Wildcats will play host to Utah in a Preseason NIT second-round game. That shouldn't come as a surprise with Rupp Arena's capacity 23,000 and the Huntsman Center's 15,000. But the Wildcats might have a tougher time getting to the second round with a first-round game against Penn in Lexington. Utah opens at home against Arkansas State.

    Meanwhile, the Wildcats are already settling into roles before practice starts on Oct. 16. Kentucky will likely use junior Saul Smith at the point with sophomore J.P. Blevins as his backup; a rotation of sophomore Desmond Allison, freshman Keith Bogans and sophomore Todd Tackett at shooting guard (Bogans may even handle the ball some times); sophomore Tayshaun Prince at small forward with 6-7 freshman Derek Smith as his backup; sophomore Jules Camara at power forward with freshman Marvin Stone as his reserve; and senior Jamaal Magloire at center with freshman Nate Knight backing him up. Smith (Highlands High/Fort Thomas, Ky.) may not be available until December if Kentucky earns a bowl berth. He's a reserve tight end on the football team and caught two passes for five yards in the first five games. Kentucky (3-2) isn't out of the bowl picture.

  • Alabama should challenge for second in the SEC West largely because of its newcomers. Tide coach Mark Gottfried said he has been extremely impressed by 6-8 freshman Rod Grizzard. He's a unique shooting guard in a forward's body. Grizzard and sophomore Schea Cotton could give the Tide one of the most athletic pairs of wings in the South. However, Cotton has been slowed by tendinitis in his knee during conditioning.

    The third newcomer who could have an impact is 6-2 freshman point Terrance Meade. The Tide need breakout perimeter players because their best returning player is center Jeremy Hays (12 ppg, 8.4 rpg). "We're just young," Gottfried said. "But I like what I'm seeing."

  • Nike is holding its annual Summit meeting in Atlanta this weekend with the keynote speaker Orlando Magic vice president Pat Williams. And for the second year in a row, Fresno State director of basketball operations Jack Fertig will be the second speaker. Fertig spoke on leadership a year ago and will talk about how it's never too late to improve yourself this year.

    But the event of the weekend will likely be the open forum, with Temple coach John Chaney, former Georgetown coach and recent Hall of Fame inductee John Thompson, Arizona State coach Rob Evans, Illinois coach Lon Kruger, Virginia athletics director Terry Holland and Augusta College (Ga.) athletics director Clint Bryant. The event is held for Nike and its coaches (mostly the summer-league coaches) but it would be worth listening in on a forum with a few of the power brokers in the game.

    Andy Katz of the Fresno (Calif.) Bee is a regular contributor to ESPN.com. The Weekly Word on college basketball will be updated on Thursdays throughout the offseason.
  •  


    ALSO SEE
    Bilas: NCAA travel rules too ambiguous

    The Word's Answer Man

    Have a question for the Weekly Word?

    Missed the Word?