M College BB
Scores/Schedules
Rankings
Standings
Statistics
Transactions
Injuries
Weekly lineup
Teams
Recruiting
 Thursday, February 17
The Word's Answer Man
 
By Andy Katz
ESPN.com

 The season's under way, which means the Word's Answer Man is down in his defensive crouch ready to take on the tough questions. If you want to send a question to the Word, click here and check back each week to see if your question was answered.

Before we get to this week's questions, a brief note. A lot of readers are upset with the Freshman Watch -- namely, who was left off the list. Readers were most upset over the omissions of Dayton's Brooks Hall, Virginia's Travis Watson, Xavier's David West, George Washington's SirValiant Brown, Indiana's Jeffrey Newton, Arizona's Gilbert Arenas, Auburn's Jamison Brewer, Ball State's Theorn Smith, Memphis' Courtney Trask and San Francisco's Darrell Tucker.

Those players shouldn't feel like they were slighted -- we just wanted to narrow the field a bit. We will admit that perhaps the "Question these five" category was a bit misleading -- it was meant more as a picking out of a fault, not a rip on the player's overall talent.

We know the above players are having decent seasons. But to give a little extra exposure, we fielded some of your responses on the subject. Thanks for the input.

Just read your column about impact freshmen, and I agree with virtually all of your picks. However, I think you might have missed a freshman to watch in Reece Gaines, Louisville's starter at the point. I have followed him since he lit up Ed Cota earlier this season, and have come away very impressed. He has excellent vision, is unselfish, and is generally an intense defender. I also like how he can raise different facets of his game (namely scoring) when his teammates aren't producing. I think he will be a star next year, and beyond. What's your impression?

    -- Roddy T., Chapel Hill, N.C.

Gaines is having an exceptional season. He's part of the reason Louisville has had quality wins against Utah and North Carolina. Gaines' ability to push the ball and keep Louisville focused has helped the Cardinals play up-tempo basketball. When they can play fast, they have a chance to win.

Any reason why you failed to even give a mention to David West (Xavier), who leads all freshmen in the country in rebounding, in any of your recent columns -- most notably the "Top 25 Centers" and the "Top 20 Freshmen"? David has stats that far surpass many of those listed in your "top" columns, including 11 points and more than nine rebounds per game. It's true that Xavier is struggling, but they would likely be a sub-.500 team without this man-child in the middle. I look forward to your reasoning.

    -- Jason, Louisville

Here's the problem. The list of top 25 centers wasn't a ranking. We looked at the centers from the top 25 teams in the ESPN/USA Today coaches poll, not the top 25 centers in the nation. West certainly deserves to be listed on a list of top 25 freshmen, but again the list that you refer to was a review of the top 20 freshmen we looked at in our season preview, not the current top 20. Your support of West is admirable, but your anger is misdirected..

Andy, I love reading your columns, they are very insightful. I have a question that you probably know a lot about. What are you to make of the rumors that BYU head coach Steve Cleveland will bolt for Fresno State when Jerry Tarkanian leaves? This way he can recruit the kind of player he wants to, and not what BYU dictates to him. Would this open the door for Danny Ainge to take over the Cougars and coach his son?

    -- Robert Rodriguez, Newport Beach, Calif.

There's something to be said of those rumors. Cleveland would be a candidate whenever Jerry Tarkanian decides to retire. Leaving BYU wouldn't be a slap against the Cougars, but more of a chance for Cleveland to go home to Fresno. It's not a definite that he would make the move, but the chance exists. Ainge has clearly stated that he won't coach his son, Austin. Austin won't be finished at BYU for seven years (two years for his mission, one redshirt season and four years of eligibility).

I know on your "magic eight" list that you said you guaranteed the national champion would come from this group. After the Syracuse-UConn game I'd like to know if you'd like to make any changes to that list?

    -- Ken Fraser, Syracuse, N.Y.

Certainly. Syracuse belongs in the top four. The Orangemen's win over Connecticut was as impressive a win as I've seen this season. There's no doubt that Syracuse can contend for the national title.

How likely is it for a school like the College of Charleston to move into a better conference? The Cougars have dominated the TAAC and have proven themselves in the Southern. Should we expect to see them moving up in the next few years?

    -- Andrew Bergstrom, Los Angeles

Not likely. The College of Charleston just moved conferences. It would be tough for it to jump again. Most of the high-level conferences demand football and Charleston can't deliver that kind of revenue. The Southern Conference is a nice fit for Charleston.

In your "Freshman Watch" article, you state that Jason Gardner is having a fantastic year yet you question Kenny Satterfield. Going by the numbers provided by ESPN up to Jan 23, Satterfield's overall numbers in terms of assists, field-goal percentage, etc., seem similar. My question -- where is the discrepancy here?

    -- Srinivasan Parthasarathy, Rochester, N.Y.

This wasn't a slight on Satterfield's overall game. In conversations with the Cincinnati coaching staff, they told me they'd like to see Kenny's shooting improve. So, we put it down as something to question. Maybe it was too early to criticize, but we're not slamming Satterfield. As for the choice, I still stick by picking Gardner over Satterfield, regardless of the statistics.

Andy, do you think getting Kareem Rush back will help stabilize the play of Missouri? Before games recently, it has been hard to tell which team is going to show up -- the one that destroyed Kansas, or the one the lost to Winthrop at home. Do you think this team can win with its small but fast lineup consistently against top competition, or will their sporadic shooting problems persist and spoil their chances?

    -- Tim Eager, Rolla, Mo.

Having Rush return to the Tigers gives them another scorer and rebounder. It could also give the Tigers the lift they'll need to continue on their recent tear through the Big 12. Missouri will likely end up as a bubble team that eventually gets into the tournament, and having Rush around helps its cause.

The boys out at Pepperdine have been pretty impressive this season, playing tough against Kansas, Auburn, and UCLA. You mentioned the 'Zags as a team on the rise, what about Pepperdine? Do the Waves have a chance to be in the Big Dance this year even if they don't win the WCC tournament?

    -- Thomas Rice, San Antonio

Pepperdine has a legitimate chance to get in with Gonzaga. In fact, I'll be surprised if they both don't get bids. The Waves have been the surprise team in that league and could pose some threat to the 'Zags when they host them in Malibu next month..

How can you honestly make the statement that Maryland has no business being in the polls? Yes, the Terps hit a temporary skid, but they have beaten some quality teams (two from the Big Ten and Kentucky). If you want to say they may not currently warrant a place in the top 25, fine, but to say they have no business being there is not an intelligent statement. Also, please see there RPI ranking and schedule strength. Not too bad, huh?

    -- Neil Carfora, New York

I still don't think Maryland should be ranked this week. I believed in Maryland at the Preseason NIT, but they've slipped over the last two months. The Terps have the talent to be a contender next season if everyone stays in school, but they're simply a victim of inexperience at times. The Terps can still contend for second in the ACC with a more favorable schedule in the second half of the conference, but they don't deserve to be ranked right now. But, hey, I don't have a vote in the AP poll this year, so my opinion doesn't factor into the polls.

Does SMU have a legitimate shot at making the tournament? After beating up on Fresno State last Saturday, what else do we need to do to help ourselves? Would a split with Tulsa and a first- or second-place finish in the WAC do?

    -- Ryan Foster, Dallas

SMU has to beat Tulsa once. If the Mustangs do, then they could get in to the field. Of course, they have to hold their ground in the WAC and finish second and get to the semifinals of the conference tournament. The San Jose State loss hurts their chances.

When does the ruling come down on the Dayton Flyers regarding the Brooks Hall issue? And what do you think the ruling will be?

    -- Mike Ruvo, Dayton, Ohio

Dayton officials told me they expect the issue to be resolved in the spring. Hall's eligibility for this season isn't in question. As a result, Dayton's season shouldn't be jeopardized by any ruling in the spring.

Why don't you adopt the policy that Billy Packer has seemed to espouse, that you will no longer make mention of how high an underclassman or a high school senior will go in the NBA draft? Why speculate and plant ideas in these kids' heads this early in their careers? It might keep the kids around longer and make the game less frantic. Gerald Wallace to the NBA -- right!?!?!

    -- Greg Mahall, Abingdon, Md.

Here's why: it's news. If NBA scouts are going to Gerald Wallace's games, that should be reported. Not reporting that fact is doing a disservice to our readers. The reports of Wallace being scouted won't force him to go to the NBA. He has plenty of people in his ear who have more influence than the simple report of what scouts think of his game.

Andy Katz is a senior writer at ESPN.com.

 



ALSO SEE
The Weekly Word on college basketball

Have a question for the Weekly Word?



AUDIO/VIDEO
video
 Get all the answers from ESPN.com's Andy Katz in this week's Ask Andy.
RealVideo:  | 28.8