M College BB
Scores/Schedules
Rankings
Standings
Statistics
Transactions
Injuries
Weekly lineup
Teams
Recruiting
 Tuesday, March 14
Who is the better freshman?
 
ESPN.com

 The Matchup:
Joseph Forte vs. Jason Gardner

The Question:
Who is the nation's best freshman?

North Carolina's Joseph Forte   Arizona's Jason Gardner
 
PPG: 15.8 | APG: 2.9 | 3-PT %: .382

By Jay Bilas
Special to ESPN.com

Because the college game has gotten younger, more freshmen are playing leading roles for their teams, and some are real impact players. Who's the best freshman? Arguments can be made for Duke's Jason Williams and Carlos Boozer, Cincinnati's Dermarr Johnson and Kenny Satterfield, Florida's Donnell Harvey, UCLA's Jason Kapono or Stanford's Casey Jacobsen.

But, it's not that simple. Each player listed above has a strength which stands out above the rest. Duke's Williams is the most explosive and the best point guard in open court situations. Johnson is the most gifted offensive weapon. Harvey is the toughest, hardest-working and most physical. UCLA's Kapono is perhaps the smartest and savviest, and Jacobsen is the top pure scorer.

But two freshmen really stand out to me: Arizona's Jason Gardner and North Carolina's Joseph Forte. And Forte is a special player.

Point guards get notice because of the importance of the position, but it would be a mistake to ignore the impact and skills of Forte. The DeMatha product scores with ease, and can shoot with range or take it off the bounce. Just as important, he looks to score and really pursues shots by working off screens and running the court.

Forte leads his team in scoring, shoots a good percentage and defends well for a freshman. He's got a toughness to his game that belies his youthful look, and he has a great on-court demeanor. Forte is quiet on the court, but plays with tenacity. He is confident without being cocky, and he is very competitive.

Two years ago, DeMatha coach Morgan Wooten told me I would really appreciate Forte's game when I saw him. "He's really special", Wooten said.

Wooten was right. Forte is a special player, and will be a great one.
  PPG: 13.4 | APG: 5.3 | 3-PT %: .427

By Andy Katz
ESPN.com

Here's what Jason Gardner was asked to do at Arizona: start at the point, become an instant leader, spearhead a defensive effort and, oh yeah, don't lose big-time matchups nearly every game.

Gardner has answered every challenge thrown at him since he arrived to replace Jason Terry. The only player to simply beat Gardner was Connecticut's Khalid El-Amin. Losing to El-Amin and the Huskies was respectable. Falling to USC and New Mexico weren't bad losses, either.

Gardner wasn't given much help, either. His primary reserves -- Ruben Douglas and Lamont Frazier -- aren't available. Douglas transferred to New Mexico. Frazier got hurt and is done for the season. His backcourt mate, Gilbert Arenas, may be one of the top freshmen in the Pac-10 but he has just as much experience as Gardner -- none.

When Mike Bibby started as a freshman at Arizona, he had the pleasure of passing to Miles Simon, Michael Dickerson, Bennett Davison and A.J. Bramlett. Gardner had experience returning in Michael Wright and Richard Jefferson inside and transfer Loren Woods. But Gardner has made sure that Arenas hasn't missed a step by getting him the ball in positions to succeed.

Arizona is a contender for the national title because of Gardner's impact at the point. Had he not come in with toughness and composure, the Wildcats would be going through the same kind of growing pains that UCLA is experiencing. Instead, the Wildcats have weathered the defections, the injuries and even the brutal schedule.

Gardner's production (13.4 points and 5.3 assists) may not be the best stats for the freshman of the year. But his impact on a team that can contend for the national title can't be put into numbers. Bibby took the Wildcats to the national title in his freshman year, a season earlier than Arizona was expected to contend. Gardner could be doing the same thing if he can continue to play with poise and passion in March.


 


ALSO SEE
The Weekly Word on college basketball

Freshman Watch

Statistical breakdown of top 20 freshmen

Poll results for top 10 freshmen by conference

Top 10 freshmen in the ACC

Top 10 freshmen in the Atlantic 10

Top 10 freshmen in the Big East

Top 10 freshmen in the Mountain West and WAC

Top 10 freshmen in the Pac-10

Top 10 freshmen in the SEC

Top 10 freshmen in Conference USA

Top 10 freshmen in the Big 12

Top 10 freshmen in the Big Ten

Top 10 freshmen in the rest of the country