ESPN Network: ESPN.com | RPM | NBA.com | NHL.com | ESPNdeportes | ABCSports | FANTASY  
rpm.espn.com
rpm.espn.com
rpm.espn.com




Wednesday, September 26
Updated: October 11, 5:52 PM ET
Robin Miller's Mailbag
Robin Miller answers user mail
ESPN.com

Check out what questions RPM.ESPN.com users had for Robin Miller -- and Robin's answers.




First, I wanted to say I enjoy your comments on CART, regardless if I agree or not. Second, I just wanted your opinion on Lola and Reynard producing chassis for the IRL? What advantage would they gain from doing this? And, are we going to see any new engine manufacturers entering CART soon?

Keith Lee
Montreal

Robin Miller: Keith: First off, thanks for the kind words. As for Reynard and Lola, it seems like a natural for them to build an IRL chassis, it's still the biggest race in the world and they obviously need as much revenue as possible. Especially Reynard (in big financial trouble I hear) and there's a chance CART could adopt a chassis rule similar to the IRL. As for engines, Audi keeps surfacing on the rumor mill but that's about it.




With the IRL losing Northern Light as title sponsor, who will pick up the sponsorship with the IRL? I love your honest opinion of racing. Is ESPN going to give you your own IRL show?

Greg O'Brien
Seymour, Ind.

Robin Miller: Greg: Thanks for you comments, hosting a show is something I'd like to try so maybe I can make it happen someday. Northern Light is in financial hell and hasn't spent a penny marketing the IRL all season. Pep Boys and Northern Light, the IRL is 0-for-2 in title sponsors, but I'm sure somebody else might come along since the Indy 500 is part of the package.




Robin, in a response to a previous question, you again urge CART to go to Watkins Glen (wouldn't that be something!), but I was surprised to hear you would like to drop Laguna Seca because today's Champ cars have "outgrown" that track. Could you explain what that means? And, are there any other tracks suffering a similar fate (with the obvious exceptions of almost every concrete canyon street course, ugh)?

Steve Barry
Chicago

Robin Miller: Steve: There hasn't been a good race at Laguna in four years because the cars are all so close that there is literally no passing. Now it may be aerodynamics and the wing package, but Laguna is pretty tight with few overtaking possibilities. It's a beautiful circuit but attendance has been steadily dropping and I think The Glen would be very successful. It's CART's one chance to out-draw NASCAR at the same track. You're right, most street circuits offer little passing opportunities but the crowds are so strong it's a tradeoff that CART must live with. Thanks.




Being from Defiance, Ohio, I am always looking for stories on Sam Hornish Jr. I find you have comments in print, but can not recall any during RPM2Night or other times you are on TV? What is your opinion of Sam's ability and, being the IRL champion, why no TV coverage from you?

Mike Ketcham
Defiance, Ohio

Robin Miller: Mike: I've championed Sam since last year when he was with PDM, both in my old newspaper, The Indianapolis Star, and on RPM2Night. Maybe you just missed those shows. But when I was at Vancouver for the CART race recently, I did a short editorial on Sam's championship. He's young, aggressive and talented. I wish he could get a good CART ride because I think he'd be a real asset. Thanks.




I love open wheel racing and am not happy about the CART/IRL split, but do you have to bash CART constantly. Just once in awhile could you concentrate on the fabulous cars, drivers and tracks that the series still provides. Good grief, look at how IRL gets people in the stands. If you want a NASCAR ticket you have to buy an IRL ticket as in the Joliet race. Lighten up a bit. There may be problems but every time I see you on RPM2Night it is mainly negative. You don't see that for NASCAR nor IRL. The other commentators do not take the same position. IRL is not in the same talent league as CART so give it it's due.

Jim Dillon
Des Plaines, Ill.

Robin Miller: Jim: True, I've been pretty critical of CART's decision making the past couples years but they deserve it and that hasn't detracted from my stance that CART is the best racing series on this planet. I said that last Saturday on RPM2Night from England. Check out ESPN.com and read the story I wrote from the England race. My position is that I have a great passion for open wheel racing and it's my job to report, critique and comment on CART and IRL. I don't care if anybody likes me, but I do believe most people trust me to tell the truth. It's cost me a lot of money and friends the past few years but I'm not about to change.




What can NASCAR possibly be thinking running a race in New Hampshire on Nov. 23? They had better pray the championship has already been decided since the quality of the race, if run, will be poor at best. Most rubber compounds don't work below 40 degrees, and this track has bitten them enough in the last two years.

Don Weidig
Massillon,Ohio

Robin Miller: Don: They could barely make it work at Atlanta for all those years. Their best option would have been to cancel the race, refund the money and make a big donation to the Red Cross instead.




As a big fan of CART and specifically Michael Andretti, I hope Alex Zanardi recovers to someday walk the CART paddock with his smiling face. My question is: With Nazareth out for next year is CART giving any consideration to Loudon, N.H., as an oval venue to accommodate New England fans?

John Mckenna
Litchfield, N.H.

Robin Miller: John: Loudon in 1993 was the scene of one of CART's great races (Mansell, Tracy and Fittipaldi) and there were 45,000 or so a couple of years but the owners felt like it wasn't enough (Until they drew 5,000 every year for the IRL). It's always a possibility and I'd like to see it happen if Watkins Glen can't be revived.




Why do you hate the IRL? They appear to have the most positive momentum in open wheel racing, they put on an incredible show every time they race, and they seem to have more television interest than CART. Can't you just admit Tony George has pulled off the creation of a great new series?

Mike Kenney
Indianapolis

Robin Miller: Mike: I don't hate the IRL, I hate the basis it was formed on and the fact Tony George diluted the Indy 500 and fractured open wheel racing. The IRL has some good people but let's get serious -- it's a spec series with big wings and low horsepower so anybody can drive the cars, be it a dentist or a slug like Marco Greco (former IRL pole winner). Sure, it's had some exciting races but no more so than CART at Michigan the past four years. Ovals are definitely more fun for the spectator but the CART series requires so much more talent. I'd love to see Sam Hornish come to CART and Buddy Lazier get a good ride and maybe somebody bring Sarah Fisher along (Toyota Atlantic) and get her involved. The IRL is basically a feeder series for CART (Kenny Brack) and NASCAR (Tony Stewart). Going to the IRL (Unser Jr.) is like going to the minors. Look at Indy the past two years. Enough said.




Please don't ever change your tell-it-like-it-is stance. What is your stance on going forward with the U.S. Grand Prix? Shame on Tony George for his greed to cover his IRL losses from the IRL having their (butts) handed to him by CART. Keep it up buddy.

Dan
Madison, Wisc.

Robin Miller: Daniel: Thanks for your support. I think it's good for everyone to go ahead with whatever was planned, you can't let terrorism continue to disrupt our society. I realize Montoya may be the only guy who really wants to come here and the track sucks for road racing, but it's still the third largest crowd in motorsports and I've always liked F1.




When you have been accused of being biased against the IRL, I have often heard you reply that a good percentage of what you write about the league is actually favorable. In that regard, how about sharing three or four specific positives you think the IRL offers, which are better than other series?

Adam
St. Louis

Robin Miller: Adam: Thanks for noticing (could you please come to Indy and tell that to some of the IRL zealots I see on the street?) I don't think the IRL doesn't anything better than anybody else, I think it's pluses are cost control and spec racing that makes for close racing. I liked the fact they passed out IRL hats at St. Louis to every fan, very smart, and they do a better job of promoting their drivers than CART.




Why doesn't CART use the results of the Indy 500 to promote it's races?

Sam Shaub
York, Pa.

Robin Miller: Sam: Excellent question. CART had a full page ad ready to go in USA Today congratulating its drivers for their performance at Indy but one owner or sponsor shot it down (my guess is Penske and Marlboro) because he didn't want to rub it in Tony George's face. Can you imagine, George has been trying to bury CART for five years and you don't want to rub anything in his face? That made me crazy and that's why CART spins its wheels so often. Why did they have to get Penske's or anybody's permission to run an ad? It was a helluva triumph -- kicking butt with the other guy's equipment. You haven't noticed Tony George promoting the Indy winner at his races the last couple years, have you?




I'll admit I enjoy NASCAR and the rough-and-tumble nature of 43 tanks careening around an assortment of battlefields. But, I am far and away a CART fan -- for exactly the opposite reason. The precision and skill of wheel-to-wheel driving at incredible speeds over a variety of circuits makes it some of the best racing in the world. However, CART is not embraced by fans at large. I can't help but wonder if CART would be more successful with its product if it applied some of NASCAR's television tricks: Driver familiarity, more on-board cameras, explanation of the cars and equipment in layman terms, and most important to me -- on board telemetry (speed, throttle, brake, g-load, gear, etc.). Television slows down the action so much that without the big fender benders and spin outs, average fans sometimes find CART boring. I believe implementing some or all of the above ideas would give fans a better idea of how fantastic these guys are. What do you think?

Jerrold White
Portland, Ore.

Robin Miller: Jerrold: I think you might need to apply for a job with CART marketing because you get it. CART is the best kept secret on this planet and for all those years it was about the owners and not the drivers. CART needs more specialty shows on television to educate the normal Joe on who these guys are and what they do. NASCAR has been masterful in that regard.




I'm from central Illinois and wondered about Donnie Beechler's future IRL career. Do you know who A.J. Foyt will go with next year?

PJ
Illinois

Robin Miller: PJ: Whomever brings him money. Honest. I think Tony George might have helped Foyt financially to run Beechler and now is making sure Greg Ray has a ride for Texas because Eddie Gossage bitched about not having anything to promote. I'd day Donnie is a good shoe but likely needs to win the lottery to keep his job in 2002.




Although I am an open wheel race fan by heart, I have a fender question. Do you foresee any foreign auto manufactures, and/or drivers in NASCAR's future, or am I just thinking way to far out of the box?

Doug Sharp
Indianapolis

Robin Miller: Doug: I keep telling Kenny Brack that NASCAR will not embrace a Swedish, open-wheel guy with blonde hair who plays in a rock band. No, I don't foresee any foreign manufacturers simply because the racers of that bunch are either in F1 or CART -- or both for the technical challenge.




Greg Ray recently stated he has had up to four offers, some from CART teams. He says he plans on staying in the IRL because it will be the series that will survive. Care to comment? Also any rumors about IRL guys moving to CART in 2002?

Slim Pridham
Powell, Ohio

Robin Miller: Slim: Greg has had a few concussions, hasn't he? No, I would be really surprised to think any CART teams made him an offer. It makes good reading though, doesn't it? I could see Hornish getting a shot, at least I think he could handle it. I'd like to see Buddy Lazier in a good CART car since he never had one before. Scott Sharp? He was a dud in CART in 1994 but that team was new and so was he. Could he cut it? Maybe. I just don't see it by next year for all of this trio.




Two years ago there was a push for African Americans in CART. What ever happened to the African American development program?

Stephen Saunders
E. Brunswick, N.J.

Robin Miller: Stephen: I think that was like the women's program CART had. It sounded like the right thing to do and made for good press. I don't care what color you are, if you can drive, you will gravitate up the ladder and someone will give you a chance. Willy Ribbs certainly had the talent, he just got hooked up with some bad equipment in CART. To answer your question, it's in the closet.




Have their been any developments on whether or not CART will be returning to Detroit?

Joe Lijoi
Shelby Twp., Mich.

Robin Miller: Joe: There is talk that CART may be back in Motown (ugh). Not at that hole, anywhere else might be OK since Michigan is gone from the sked. An airport, an oval, anywhere would be fine except Hell's Belle Isle.




Is there any chance of Adrian Fernandez racing at Indy next year? He is an expert on the big ovals and surely his sponsors can foot the bill.

Jeff Rayer
Cleveland

Robin Miller: Jeff: Absolutely, I know his team manager has been talking with IRL teams about a co-op program and his sponsors are interested.




I'm a fan from your Star News days and I used to count the days between your answers. I'm glad to see you are continuing the tradition. Regarding CART's new TV package. We used to complain about the poor coverage on ABC and ESPN, so why are we complaining about CART changing channels? All true motorsport fans get Speedvision, and only true motorsports fans watch CART. But, think about the possibilities. Don't European F1 TV viewers get multiple feeds and channels? Wouldn't it be great of CART could do the same? One channel for race action, timing and scoring, in-car cameras? Of course, the real question is, does CART's leadership have the creativity to pull it off? Bonus question: Did Paul Page help or hinder CART? Please keep on doing what you're doing. You're one of the very few sane voices in the world of motorsports.

Jim Schiavone
Apex, N.C.

Robin Miller: Jim: I think CART has plans in that multi-channel area but the tough part is getting SpeedVision to all the right markets. Milwaukee doesn't have it, for one, and there are only 40 million homes compared to 90 million on ESPN. That hurts but Joe Heitzler did good to get what he did considering CART's ratings the past few years. I've always been one of Page's biggest critics and it's time for a change in the booth. But, having said that, announcers won't fix .08 ratings. The whole TV package needs an overhaul and I think it will get one.




Will CART go normally aspirated or, have you heard rumors that the momentum to keep the turbos might be building? What's your feeling at this point?

Mark Bette
Chicago

Robin Miller: Mark: I can honestly say I have no clue about that anymore. I heard in England that the only way Audi would be interested in CART was to stay turbocharged but that doesn't help anybody like Ford or Honda at Indy. I just wish somebody would make a decision and get on with it.




What are you talking about when you call the IRL a feeder system for NASCAR and CART? I can only can come up with four drivers that left the IRL -- two in NASCAR (Tony Stewart and Jason Leffler) and two in CART (Kenny Brack and Michel Jourdain). You could count Richie Hearns, but he has no ride in CART. Who, if any, have I missed? Thanks for taking my question. My thoughts are with Alex Zanardi.

Don Newcomb
Middletown, Ohio

Robin Miller: Don: I realize that's a stretch, but I have to laugh when Tony George is gong to spend $15 million for a feeder system for the IRL. The IRL is a feeder system, the few guys who make it out go up in their career and the guys (like Unser) who are heading the other way. Hornish certainly would be somebody who I'd like to see get a good CART chance. Thank you. Check out my latest story on Zanardi on RPM.ESPN.com.




It seems to me that CART needs a good kick in the pants from their fans. Their viewership is bad, their track choices are highly questionable, their on-track calls are obtuse and their business decisions seem off base. Some things they have done recently garner hope; I like the European challenge against F1's "dreary road course bore sessions" with the German 500 and Rockingham 500; but giving up on Michigan? They really should have made a greater effort to gain support for the best race on the planet. Aside from having to change the TV channel, what can fans do to inspire CART to listen to the criticisms from their fans? Also, can we expect the same great coverage from you next year when CART moves to another network?

Adam Sorensen
Salt Lake City

Robin Miller: Adam: Yes, CART needs several swift kicks in the head and butt for some of the dumb things its down on the past couple years. The European races were a big success, despite the weather and leaky track and lack of practice. I don't know if CART gave up on Michigan or Michigan (read NASCAR) gave up on CART because the IRL made them a much better financial chance. Just send CART letters and emails and vent whenever you can. I hope I can continue to cover racing for RPM and ESPN.com, they've been very supportive and given me two great forums. thanks.




Line up the top 12 cars from F1 and the top 12 from CART. A home-and-home series, say Monaco and Watkins Glen. Race what ya' brung as long as it conforms to one series regs, either. I'd watch it.

Mike Sevier
Tucson, Ariz.

Robin Miller: Mike: Yeah, bring 'em to Elk Lake and then Milwaukee. That's what I'd pay to see.




Is Mark Blundell still working on getting back into to Champ Cars? I always felt he got a little screwed with the Mercedes support after his three-win season. I feel he deserves another shot.

Robert Delgado
Whittier, Calif.

Robin Miller: Robert: I talked to Mark last weekend in England, he's trying to line up an Indy 500 ride and wants to go back to testing F1 cars in addition to staying in sports cars. He was a good racer caught in a bad situation, I agree.




Why don't American companies (Ford, Compaq, Phillip Morris, etc.) that spend big bucks in F1 try to get American drivers into that series? Don't you think there are plenty of experienced American open wheel guys (Memo Gidley, Bryan Herta, etc.) who can blow the doors off half the current F1 field?

Tim Brandt
Waukegan, Ill.

Robin Miller: Tim: Not blow the doors off, but maybe able to compete. Montoya says Franchitti is the only CART driver currently ready for F1 but maybe a Buddy Rice in a couple years with the right training. I think Rahal's goal was to get a Yank in a Jaguar car but that ain't happening now.




What is the answer to NASCAR changing the rules every week? The fans would see a better car on the track if the rules were left alone week to week.

Jim Fraley
Silver Springs, Fla.

Robin Miller: Jim: NASCAR can do whatever it wants because it always has and it works.




Robin, we ran into Scott Pruett at Turn 5 at Elkhart Lake and gave him what we thought was a great sign for you. He said he'd give it to you, and we're just wondering if he did. It read simply, "Robin Miller for CART CEO." Did you ever get it? We thought for sure either he, or you, would display it on RPM2Night. And by the way, would you ever want the job? Just curious. Thanks and keep up the great work.

John Leski & John Berry
Green Bay, Wisc.

Robin Miller: John and John: I didn't get it yet but thanks for the thought. Sure, I'd love to run CART but I don't think the owners would go along with that plan. thanks anyway.

Send this story to a friend | Most sent stories
 

Related
Submit your questions to Robin Miller

Robin Miller answers user mail: Sept. 10

RPM user comment central

Sports Mall