Readers: Best Browns of all time
From the Page 2 mailbag

Earlier this week, Page 2 listed its choices for the 10 best Browns of all-time. We knew our readers would be able to come up with a few more sweet Brownies so we opened it up to them.

We received more than 300 letters on the topic, and here's how the readers ranked their 10 favorite Browns of all time. Be sure to vote in the poll at right to crown the best Brown in history.

1. Charlie Brown (67 letters)
Charlie Brown
Chuck is the ultimate multi-sport star, earning this blockhead top billing.
Here was a young man who embodied all that is right about sports. Instead of simply giving lip service to the phrase, he actually played for the love of the game. Despite being surrounded by the damndest collection of talent ever assembled on a ball field, he persevered without pointing fingers or asking to be traded to a winner.

In a world where the sports section is plastered with stories of whining, money-grubbing superstars, Charlie Brown represented the joy we all felt as kids the first time we went to a ball game with our dads or played basketball in the driveway until our moms called us to dinner. Long live sports and long live Charlie Brown.
Wayne Buck
Seattle

He's the ultimate everybody.

We have all had frustrations in love, as he did with the red-headed girl. We have all had games -- sometime seasons -- where nothing has gone right. Yet, every bad memory is easily washed away by that one heroic feat in our lives. For some, it's a last-second basket, for others it is the fourth quarter TD, or, in Charlie Brown's case, it is a walk-off, game-winning home run to win it all and forget everything else.
Travis Smith
Cromwell, Min.

I saw this week's list and immediately noticed Jim Brown was in there near the bottom ... I couldn't believe it! Imagine my joy when I read deeper into the article and saw my hero -- Charlie Brown, the ultimate underdog -- there at the top of your list. Charlie Brown transcends sports and mere animation. Charlie Brown is Americana at its finest and there is no better role model than Chuck and his never-say-die attitude.
Brega Fireforge
Old Bridge, N.J.

Good grief, Charlie wins in a landslide. His love of sports and his unconditional loyalty and devotion to his teams never wavered, even through decades of futility.

Charlie would have made a perfect Philadelphia sports fan. We've had an endless series of Joe Shlabotniks pass through town. More than a few Phillies pitchers have ended up undressed by a line drive through the box. None of us in the Delaware Valley will ever forget the Monday night game when the Eagles lined up for a last-second chip shot field goal that would have beaten the detested Cowboys ... only to have holder Tom Hutton morph into Lucy Van Pelt and muff a perfect snap.

Ohh, but despite it all, we go out to the Vet, year after year, and root passionately for our teams, even though we know in our hearts that C.B. has more career home runs (two) than the Phillies and Eagles have World Championships, combined (one).
Nick Straguzzi
Mullica Hill, N.J.

2. Jim Brown (32 letters)
If it wasn't for the fact he fathered Mike, Paul would top my list. That said, Jim needs to top the list. Jim was not only a top football player in his day (we all know where that career went), but a top lacrosse player in college. If it wasn't for the minor fact there wasn't a lacrosse league, he would have played that too.

Jim was the all-time rushing leader until a guy named Sweetness came onto the scene, and the only reason he broke it so quickly was because Jim retired with some years left in him. If Jim had stayed, he would perhaps still be the all-time rushing leader.
David Heit
Englewood, Colo.

Jim Brown
Jim Brown drips with unparalleled style on and off the football field.
Let me get this straight: you ranked arguably the greatest football player ever behind a cartoon character and a song?
Mark Polishuk
Ontario, Calif.

This list is completely invalid if Jim Brown doesn't top it. Brown was undoubtedly the best running back of all time. For all those 80-yard runs by Barry Sanders and Gale Sayers, Brown was the only running back in NFL history with a significant amount of carries, to average 5 yards per carry. Imagine knowing you've got a first down in the bag in two plays!

Not only that, Brown may have been the best athlete in modern U.S. sports period. If you know anything about the game of lacrosse, you'll know that probably the best lacrosse player in the modern history of the game was also Jim Brown. A true sports great.
Jerry Edwards
Halfmoon, N.Y.

3. Bad, Bad Leroy Brown (28 letters)

Jim Croce's "Bad, Bad Leroy Brown" is the greatest of all time. I mean, he's the baddest man in the whole damn town! You can't compete with this guy, he's a through-and-through winner.
Matthew Ryan Gephart
Lansing, Ill.

Now Leroy's more than trouble
You see he stand 'bout 6 foot 4
All the downtown ladies call him "Treetop Lover"
All the mens just call him "Sir"
Jim
Bethlehem, Pa.

Charlie Brown? He can't hold a candle to Leroy Brown. He would've beaten up Chuck, taken his lunch money, and started dating the little red-headed girl.
Chris Dalton
Norman, Okla.

4. James Brown (25 letters)
How could you leave the Godfather of Soul off your list of the top Browns! If it's not enough involvement in sports, simply consider his participation in the Rumble in the Jungle ... or at least providing an excellent soundtrack for Rocky IV with "When We Were Kings." I mean, if Charlie Brown makes the list for moderate sports-related laughs, than there is no excuse for leaving James Brown off.
Nicole
San Francisco

Because of his music. Because of that hair. C'mon, he's "The Hardest Working Man in Show Business," he's "Mr Dynamite," "Soul Brother Number One" you gotta give him some credit!
James Williams
Arlington, Texas

5. Tim Brown (22 letters)
Tim Brown
Tim Brown is a picture of consistency.
One of the best receivers of all time. He also has remained a Raider for his entire career.

Just look at who he had throwing the ball to him -- Jay Shroeder, Todd Marinovich, Steve Beurlein, Jeff George, Jeff Hostetler, Vince Evans, Billy Joe Hobert, and Rich Gannon (just to name a few). Imagine if he had had one or two steady QBs his entire career. He would probably be even better ... kinda like another Raider. TB is the best Brown without a doubt.
R. Beasley
Oakley, Calif.

Tim Brown's backup is the greatest player to ever step on a football field. Charlie can't say that.
Bill Johnson
Des Moines, Iowa

The coolest Brown of all time is clearly Tim Brown. I don't need to rattle off the numbers. Simply put, he is a model of consistency.
David
Reno, Nev.

6. Mordecai "Three Fingers" Brown (20 letters)
Ninety-four years later, and still the last Cubs pitcher to win the deciding game of a World Series.
Brett Gray
Winston-Salem, N.C.

He had the ugliest curve ball ever -- not even Randy Johnson could make the batters' knees buckle as well as "3 Fingers." He deserves the No. 1 spot just because he played without 40 percent of his pitching hand.
Danny D.
Akron, Ohio

This guy was the man. Legend has it he once called the entire team behind him in and instructed them to sit behind him on the field as he pitched to the opposition because he was so confident they wouldn't even be able to make contact. There's never been a ballsier Brown, that's for sure.
Horatio Funderburke
New York

7. Hubie Brown (16 letters)
Hubie Brown
A Brown list without Hubie lacks upside, tremendous upside.
You create the list because Hubie "Upside" Brown gets hired and then he doesn't even get an honorable mention?! This man still has upside that hasn't even been tapped yet.

He was an excellent TV man for TNT for over 10 years, and can give you a real coach's point of view while keeping it simple enough for the fans. Now, we get to see Hubie find some upside in Jason Williams. Too bad The Sports Guy went Hollywood, because he would have to agreed to give Hubie a spot on this list. Without Hubie, this list is a downer.
Matt Camp
Bergenfield, N.J.

Now, you're Hubie Brown. You're trying to crack Page 2's Top 10 Brown's of all-time list. You did some dynamite coaching work in the early 1980s, not to mention classic NBA draft broadcasts throughout the '90s. Now you've got the chance, thanks to the nod from Jerry West, to take over a very young team and build it up to its full potential. You know that you're going to make the list because Page 2 readers know you've got upside, nothing but upside.
Matt Geiszler
San Diego

8. Larry Brown (14 letters)
He won a couple of ABA titles, turned the NBA's Indiana Pacers into a respectable Eastern Conference power, and led the Sixers to the NBA Finals two years ago despite Allen Iverson's distractions. Did I mention that he was a good basketball player, too?
Thomas
Chico, Calif.

Larry Brown
Larry Brown's flexibility is definitely List worthy.
The fact he led a pathetic franchise such as the Los Angeles Clippers to the playoffs twice in two years should alone seal his place in the top 10. However, in addition to that amazing feat, he proved that he could succeed as a college and pro basketball player and as a college and pro basketball coach. What hasn't he done?

He led Kansas to a national championship in the late '80s and the Jayhawks have not even come close to winning another one despite having great talent year after year. He also turned around perennial losers such as the Spurs, Pacers, and Sixers. Finally, see if another coach can deal with Allen Iverson and still win games the way Larry Brown does.
Steve Gaydon
Coal Township, Pa

9. Jerome Brown (13 letters)
We must at least mention the late, great Jerome Brown who along with Reggie White and others, anchored one of the best defenses ever in the NFL for the Eagles in the late '80s and early '90s.

Jerome didn't get all the publicity that Reggie White got, but he was a vital part of that defense which finished the '91 season No. 1 against the run, No. 1 against the pass and No. 1 overall. Not to mention carried an Eagles team to a 10-6 record with Jim McMahon, Brad Goebel, Jeff Kemp and Pat Ryan filling in for an injured Randall Cunningham. I'm having nightmares just thinking about it.
Mike Scarcella
Winston Salem, N.C.

Jerome Brown is the best Brown of them all, or at least should be in the top 10. He was the embodiment of the Miami Hurricanes of the mid- to late 80s. He went on to the Eagles and became one of the greatest defensive tackles. If his life hadn't been tragically cut short he probably would be considered the greatest defensive tackle ever.

Plus, he lavished upon us some classic sound bites like, "They got the house, we'll bring the pain," in reference to the now infamous 1990 House of Pain game on Monday night against the Oilers.
Steve Marston
Philadelphia

10. Lou Brown (10 letters)
You know ... the manager of the Cleveland Indians in "Major League".

Reluctant to take the managerial job of the Indians stating, "Oh I don't know Charlie, I got a guy on the other line about some whitewalls, I'll call ya later." C'mon, he motivated his club using the bait of the scantily clad, cardboard cutout of the relocation-happy, former lounge singer, bequeathed owner Rachel Phelps. Lou is a classic.
Jonathan Halitsky
New York

Forget about the other Browns on this list, my vote goes for good ol' Lou. How can he not be the greatest? He'd rather sell tires than coach the Indians. He took a bunch of has-beens and never-will-bes and turned them into AL pennant winners.

We all remember his pregame speech at the beginning of the season ... "Most of the writers have picked us to finish dead last. They seem to think that we'd all be saving them a lot of time if we just went out and shot ourselves." In real life (as opposed to reel life), I think a manager who was honest and straight-forward would be a relief by today's standards.

Movie or not, Lou Brown took a hopeless team and turned them into a champion! He gets my vote.
Travis Lavin
San Jose, Calif.

He was brilliant enough to figure out that all Ricky Vaughn needed was a pair of glasses. Plus, he spouted out more classic lines than Yogi Berra ... "You may run like Hayes, but you hit like s#*%"

No list of Browns is complete without him.
David Baker
New York

Honorable mention

  • The Brown Bomber (Joe Louis)
  • UPS
  • Brown University
  • Dee Brown
  • Browning Neagle
  • Gilbert Brown
  • Walter Brown
  • Troy Brown





  • ALSO SEE:


    The List: Best Browns of all time

    The Readers' List: Sports clichés that must go

    The Readers' List: Greatest NFL records

    The Readers' List: Baseball's other great moments

    The Readers' List: Biggest baseball playoff upsets

    The Readers' List: Bliss for Yankee haters

    The Readers' List: Biggest Heisman flops

    The Readers' List: Best NFL defenses of all time

    The Readers' List: Best NFL offenses of all time

    The Readers' List: Worst college football teams of all time

    The Readers' List: Best college football teams of all time

    The Readers' List: Worst NFL teams of all time

    The Readers' List: Greatest NFL teams of all time

    The Readers' List: Worst baseball deadline trades of all time

    The Readers' List: Most shocking moment in NFL history

    The Readers' List: Most shocking moment in baseball history

    The Readers' List: Greediest owners in sports

    The Readers' List: Overpaid baseball players

    The Readers' List: Biggest championship losses

    The Readers' List: Most painful losses in baseball history

    The Readers' List: Ex-hoopsters who should be in Hall

    The Readers' List: Best NBA Finals performances

    The Readers' List: Biggest chokes in Stanley Cup playoff history

    The Readers' List: Biggest cheaters in baseball history

    The Readers' List: Dirtiest professional team players

    The Readers' List: Worst championship teams

    The Readers' List: Best NHL playoff performances

    The Readers' List: Most overpaid NBA players

    The Readers' List: Most disappointing teams of past year

    The Readers' List: All-time clutch performers

    The Readers' List: Worst choke artists of all-time

    The Readers' List: Big-game college hoops coaches

    Readers' list: Worst teams to be a fan of

    Readers' list: Worst sports scandals

    Readers' list: Lists you'd like to see

    Readers' list: Most overrated sporting events

    Readers' list: Most memorable Super Bowl moments

    Readers' list: Best Super Bowl commercials





    ESPN TOOLS
     
    Email story
     
    Most sent
     
    Print story
     





    espn Page 2 index