NFL
Scores
Schedules
Standings
Statistics
Transactions
Injuries
Players
Message Board
NFL en español
FEATURES
NFL Draft
Super Bowl XXXVII
Photo gallery
Power Rankings
NFL Insider
CLUBHOUSE


ESPN MALL
TeamStore
ESPN Auctions
SPORT SECTIONS
Monday, October 18
Updated: October 19, 12:36 PM ET
 
Revolving door keeps spinning for QBs

By Dave Goldberg
Associated Press

Dan Marino leaves and Damon Huard plays just fine as his replacement. Same for Jay Fiedler in place of Mark Brunell. Even Brian Griese has found new life, and Dave Brown is back for a while.

Jay Fiedler
Jay Fiedler replaced the injured Mark Brunell and sparked the Jaguars offense.
Such is the way of the NFL, where Kurt Warner can come out of the Arena League and lead the downtrodden St. Louis Rams to five consecutive wins to start the season.

Such is the way of NFL fans, who were chanting "Fied-ler, Fied-ler," after the journeyman from Dartmouth went 11-for-13 to pull out a win for the Jaguars after Brunell went down.

Nonetheless, there is reason for concern in a sport in which one position plays so prominent a role. With the season one-third complete, 14 of the 31 first-string quarterbacks have been injured -- some temporarily, some for the season and one (Steve Young) perhaps for his career.

A partial list:

  • Marino, the NFL's career leader in most passing categories, completed one pass Sunday in New England. He threw an 8-yarder on the second play of the game that made him the first QB to surpass 60,000 yards in his career. Then he left with a sore shoulder, giving way to Huard. The third-year pro from Washington won the game 31-30 on a 5-yard TD pass to Stanley Pritchett with 23 seconds left.

  • Brunell, the player most responsible for Jacksonville's early success as an expansion franchise, bruised his ribs with the underachieving Jaguars trailing expansion Cleveland 7-6 in the third quarter. Enter Fiedler, a relative of the late conductor Arthur Fielder and a quarterback who has bounced from Philadelphia to Minnesota to Jacksonville in four years. Fifteen points later, the Jags win 24-7.

     
    Damon Huard
    Quarterback
    Miami Dolphins
    Profile
     
     
    1999 SEASON STATISTICS
    COMP ATT YDS TD INT RAT
    24 42 240 2 1 79.5

  • Jake Plummer was already playing with a variety of injuries that have kept him from fulfilling the promise shown last season. He broke his right index finger in a 24-10 loss to the Redskins. Enter Brown, a one-time first-round draft choice run out of New York by the boos of Giants fans. Brown threw a TD pass that got the Cards back in the game temporarily.

  • Detroit's Charlie Batch, another bright young QB. He left the game with Minnesota with a bruised right shoulder, believed not to be overly serious. In the same game, another maligned QB, Jeff George, took over for an ineffective Randall Cunningham. George nearly won the game out for the Vikings and will start next week.

  • Then there's Brett Favre, who had pulled out all three of Green Bay's wins with touchdown drives in the final minutes. Playing with a thumb injury that causes constant pain, he had the worst game of his career in Denver. He completed seven of 23 passes for 120 yards with three interceptions in a 31-10 loss to the Broncos. "My thumb has been bothering me all year, but it is not an excuse," Favre said. "I don't want it to be."

  • Griese was supposed to be benched until Bubby Brister came up with a strained rib muscle. But he threw for 363 yards in that game. Coach Mike Shanahan, playing quarterback roulette all season, declined to say if Brister or Griese will start next week.

  • Finally, is the 49ers' Young. He wanted to come back in the second half of San Francisco's game in Arizona Sept. 27 after sustaining yet another concussion in the first half.

    Instead, he's missed three games now, and the unrelated Steinbergs, agent Leigh and Dr. Gary, seem to want him to retire. The agent is outspoken; the doctor is guarded.

    In his stead, Jeff Garcia has done decently.

    But he's not Steve Young.

    Nor can Huard be Marino.

    In this year of declining and emerging quarterbacks, only Kurt Warner has looked like a superstar.

    And he's had only five games. Give him time.

    End of the gold rush
    It finally looks as if San Francisco's fabulous run is near an end. Not because Young has been replaced by Garcia at quarterback, but because the rest of the parts aren't there.

    The Niners lost 31-29 to Carolina Sunday, ending a 19-game regular-season home winning streak in a strangely symmetrical fashion.

    Their last regular-season loss at home was 30-24 to the Panthers on Dec. 8, 1996. George Seifert was San Francisco's coach in that game.

    Seifert, eased out as Niners' coach after that '96 season despite a career winning percentage of .766, was the Panthers coach Sunday. He returned as the enemy for the first time to the city where he was born, raised and spent most of his coaching career.

    "I'm as excited as I can be," he said after the game, about as strong a statement as the laid-back Seifert ever makes.

    As for the 49ers, they're 3-3 with a bad secondary and questionable offensive and defensive lines. In a league where parity reigns, they might not win 10 games this season, ending a run of 16 consecutive seasons with double-figure wins.

    Breeding Bulldogs
    With Terrell Davis and Derek Loville injured, Denver turned to rookie Olandis Gary on Sunday. He responded with a heavy-duty 124 yards on 37 carries. That was a major reason why the Broncos had the ball for an astounding 45 minutes, 14 seconds in their 31-10 victory over the Packers.

    There's a connection here.

    Gary was a fourth-round pick from Georgia. That's the same school from which the Broncos plucked Davis, who won Super Bowl MVP and league MVP awards the last two years, in the sixth round in 1995.

    There's another connection.

    Davis transferred to Georgia from Long Beach State after it dropped football. He got hurt, then got caught in a pass-happy offense led by Eric Zeier.

    Gary came from Marshall with Jim Donnan, who moved from there to Georgia to replace Ray Goff in 1996, the year after Zeier and Davis left. He was a backup to the injured Robert Edwards of the New England Patriots before becoming a starter last season.

    Maybe that's Denver's secret: Draft Georgia running backs late.





  •  More from ESPN...
    Tuesday Morning Quarterback
    Damon Huard? Jay Fiedler? We ...

    Murphy: Slapping us silly
    ESPN.com's Brian Murphy is ...

    ESPN.com's NFL Power Rankings
    The Rams remain at No. 1, but ...

    Rookie Report 6
    An early Champ has emerged in ...

    Week 6 wrap-ups
    The Dolphins scored a ...

    Week 6 infirmary report
    It's been a rough day so far ...

    TJ's Take: Rams still on top of mountain
    ESPN's Tom Jackson says the ...

    Week 6 PrimeTime Players
    A backup quarterback, three ...

     ESPN Tools
    Email story
     
    Most sent
     
    Print story
     
    Daily email