ESPN Network: ESPN | NBA.com | NHL.com | ABC | Radio | EXPN | Insider | Shop | Fantasy

John Clayton

Keyword
NFL
Scores
Schedules
Standings
Statistics
Transactions
Injuries
Photo gallery
Players
Power Rankings
Message Board
NFL en español
CLUBHOUSE


SHOP@ESPN.COM
TeamStore
ESPN Auctions
SPORT SECTIONS
MLB
   Scores | GameCast
NFL
   Scores
Col. Football
   Scores
NBA
   Scores
Golf
   Scores
Tennis
   Scores
Motorsports
Soccer
Boxing
NHL
M Col. BB
W Col. BB
WNBA
Horse Racing
Recruiting
Sports Business
College Sports
Olympic Sports
Action Sports
ESPNdeportes
ProRodeo
More Sports
Friday, September 27
Updated: September 29, 11:17 AM ET
 
Injuries have led to a lack of depth

By John Clayton
ESPN.com

In studying why the National Football Conference has gone "south" in the first three weeks of the season, the symptoms seem to point to depth.

Depth charts have become misnomers. Most teams lack depth. They may build up in one or two positions, but others remain thin in case of injury. That's the NFL in the salary-cap era, and it's compounded by the expansion to 32 teams.

Taking 62 players, including practice squanders, out of the pool of stretched talent has had an impact. Teams already are complaining about how well the Texans are doing in their first season, and they should start to jump toward contention next year with the addition of 15 draft choices. The Texans will have depth next year.

Jeremiah Trotter
The Eagles have survived the offseason move that allowed Trotter (54) to join Washington.
As it was last year with the Patriots emerging from the pack as a surprise team, it's becoming more and more apparent that this is a changing league, changing for the good of all the fans and for worse for general managers and coaches.

For hours upon end, I've stared at depth charts and standings trying to figure what's going on. The NFC, for example, has elite teams, top players and great managers. An argument can be made that the Saints might be the NFC's best team after three weeks. They won the three toughest opening games in recent NFL history and have set themselves up for a possible top seed because they really have only three tough games in the final 13, all three at home.

The Saints revamped the roster, trading away or releasing big-name stars, but they bounced back with a roster that's younger, faster and deeper, particularly on the offensive line, than a year ago. For that, general manager Randy Mueller lost his job. Bizarre.

Still, the rest of the NFC is down. The Eagles are the next best team, but the loss of defensive tackle Hollis Thomas to injury and middle linebacker Jeremiah Trotter to free agency leaves them one injury from disaster in the run game. Their gamble is that they are better served with Levon Kirkland and Barry Gardner than putting all their money to Trotter.

The rest of the teams at the top of the NFC are troubled. The Bears lost a little of their defensive swagger with the injuries to defensive linemen Phillip Daniels and Ted Washington and cornerback R.W. McQuarters. The Packers defense isn't tackling well and they got thinner this week with injuries to two former first-rounders -- defensive end Vonnie Holliday and safety Antuan Edwards. The 49ers have to resort to rookies on the offensive line after losing guard Dave Fiore for the season with a knee injury. The Rams and Bucs are ridiculously thin on the offensive line. The Packers aren't that much different.

If anything, the conditions of the offensive line might dictate the NFC race. The deep-seeded problem with the Rams is their offensive line. In three games against good front-four defensive linemen, the Rams offensive front five was manhandled. The constant hits on Kurt Warner in each series have caused his inconsistency even though his completion percentage is better than a year ago.

The Bucs entered the season with four different starters on their offensive line, but it's the line that could ultimately bring the offense crashing. Tough guard Kerry Jenkins is considering playing this week despite a slightly cracked bone in his leg and they need him. Right tackle Kenyatta Walker is out for a month, and Cornell Green has to handle the position for the next month. He was a third-string offensive tackle for the Dolphins.

General managers can't afford to whine about the realities of how thin rosters are, but it is interesting to note how some teams have adjusted their thinking to do different things.

"The system is set up so that you can't stockpile talent for a long period of time," Giants general manager Ernie Accorsi said. "If you lose two offensive linemen to injury, there really isn't anything you can do."

The Giants gambled on a strategy that might work, but if it works, the answer lies in the skills of the offensive line coach. Thin positions require great coaching, and the Giants have a great one in Jim McNally. McNally shunned the options of signing cheap veterans and went with a young group of unknowns -- Rich Seubert, Jason Whittle, Chris Bober and Mike Rosenthal on a line with former first-rounder Luke Petitgout. The Giants survived the first three games with a 2-1 record and good performances from quarterback Kerry Collins.

Center Dusty Zeigler is getting healthier and may be able to contribute in the next few weeks now that his microfracture repaired knee is better.

Chargers offensive line coach Hudson Houck, who did wonders with the Cowboys offensive line, may have to pull miracles in San Diego. The Chargers lost center Cory Raymer for the season, and Houck is going with his second rookie, undrafted center Jason Ball. Ball will play next to rookie second-rounder Toniu Fonoti.

One of the reasons that the AFC has an edge over the NFC is that some of the coaches have succeeded with some bold, risky gambles.

Here are a few examples:

  • The Dolphins kept their eyes open for line help and didn't care where it came from. They made sure that their first choice in the draft was an offensive lineman, and they felt good about third-round choice Seth McKinney, who can help them at guard or center. Their biggest surprise was signing Jamie Nails, a former 370-pounder who coaches high school linemen not too far from the Dolphins headquarters. Nails trimmed himself to 335 pounds and won the starting left guard job. The Dolphins lost tackle Brent Smith for the season and Leon Searcy suffered an injury that forced his release. Still, watching the Dolphins run the ball, you don't notice any problems and they have depth.

  • Bill Belichick made a point of having tackles playing guard and guards playing tackle. He had other linemen jump into the center mix when necessary. That versatility has made injuries not that much of a deal. The Patriots may not have Joe Andruzzi or Damien Woody for Sunday's game against the Chargers, but no problem. Converted tackle Adrian Klemm looked good at guard and Grey Ruegamer is an option for Woody at center, but Ruegamer can also play guard. Meanwhile, Greg Robinson-Randall, a starter on a Super Bowl team, has been inactive. That's depth.

  • Offensive line coaches hate sending talented, young offensive linemen to NFL Europe, but it's made the Broncos offensive lines one of the best. Forty percent of the Broncos offensive line was developed in NFL Europe, including high-paid tackle Matt Lepsis, one of the spring league's great success stories. Left guard Lennie Friedman, another NFL Europe product, broke a thumb before the regular-season opener, and he was replaced by Ben Hamilton, who had one of the best NFL Europe blocking seasons ever this spring.

    "This league needs to develop more offensive linemen, particularly right tackles," Ravens vice president Ozzie Newsome said. "The lack of quality right tackles is becoming a problem. Maybe we have to look more to NFL Europe to do that."

    There are currently 32 NFL Europe players on active rosters, but sending them over doesn't come without risks. Playing a 10-game season stretches the talent thinner and leaves the team vulnerable to having the prospect get hurt. That becomes a cap liability that limits the chances to find replacements.

    Only about 24 new players from NFL Europe made NFL teams this year while 31 had injuries that knocked them out for this season or required injury settlements.

    Still, no matter how well a team plans it, two or three injuries at a position bring a team to its knees. Right now, the NFC is wobbling while the AFC crosses its fingers.

    John Clayton is a senior writer for ESPN.com.







  •  More from ESPN...
    Pasquarelli: Tip Sheet
    New Panthers coach John Fox ...
    Clayton: First ... And 10
    For the second straight year, ...

    John Clayton Archive

     ESPN Tools
    Email story
     
    Most sent
     
    Print story
     
    Daily email
     



    ESPN.com: Help | PR Media Kit | Sales Media Kit | Contact Us | Tools | Jobs at ESPN.com | Supplier Information | Copyright ©2007 ESPN Internet Ventures. Terms of Use and Privacy Policy and Safety Information/Your California Privacy Rights are applicable to this site. Employment opportunities at ESPN.