|
Monday, November 13 Florida-Florida St. winner could jump Miami By Brad Edwards Special to ESPN.com |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Three weeks remain in college football's regular season, but most of the national championship picture will be very clear after this weekend. After dodging a major bullet in College Station on Saturday, Oklahoma held on to its No. 1 spot in the BCS Rankings, while Miami jumped over Florida State for the No. 2 position. Florida moved up to No. 4 and now gets a chance to make its claim for a spot in the FedEx Orange Bowl.
Florida race too close to call Of course, this will change after Saturday, when FSU plays 9-1 Florida and Miami takes on 5-4 Syracuse. Miami then has one more game against 6-4 Boston College. What this means is that both teams should finish in the top 10 for schedule strength. Who places higher may come down to the wins and losses of their key opponents (see chart below), although close may be good enough for the Seminoles. The computer margin between FSU and Miami will probably not finish at exactly one point, so a change in either direction would be huge for one team. Provided Oklahoma also wins out, here are the battleground areas in the computers that might decide the race between the Seminoles and Hurricanes -- the numbers behind the numbers, if you will. Keep in mind that each spot of movement causes a change of .14 points for that team in the overall BCS score. Sagarin Computer: Nebraska ranks third at 97.23 points and Miami is fourth at 96.59, which is a fairly small gap. Miami has a chance to move into third place. Anderson & Hester Computer/Seattle Times: Washington ranks second and Miami is third. If Washington loses this weekend, Miami would move up to second. Billingsley Computer: Florida ranks third, and Miami is fourth. A Florida loss to FSU should move Miami up a spot. Dunkel Index: Oklahoma ranks first at 119.0 points. Florida State is second at 118.9. There is a chance FSU could climb back into first in these ratings. Matthews Computer/Scripps-Howard: Washington ranks third, Florida is fourth and Miami is fifth. If Washington and Florida lose, Miami could move all the way up to third. This would be huge because this computer is the one currently not considered in the Hurricanes' average. Rothman Computer: Miami ranks second at 79.20 points, while FSU is third at 79.19. Obviously, this is about as tight as it can get, and it stands to be the most important battleground of them all. If these teams switch places, it would account for almost three-tenths of a point in the overall standings.
Gators in striking distance Florida should finish ahead of the Canes in schedule strength, so a one-point computer advantage would likely be enough for them. But would they climb that high? It's tough to project what the average would be in this scenario, but it seems that Florida would move to No. 2 in most of the computers. We'll know soon enough.
Key opponent games
Miami
Florida State
Florida
File this one away You want controversy? Try this scenario on for size. Miami loses at Syracuse, Oregon beats Oregon State, Washington beats Washington State and Oklahoma loses the Big 12 title game to Kansas State (in Kansas City) -- all very possible outcomes. This would make the Florida-Florida State winner the No. 1 team in the nation and likely place Washington -- the Pac-10 runner-up -- as the opponent in the FedEx Orange Bowl. You think the current FSU-Miami possibility would be bad? How about a No.2 team that not only lost to the No. 3 team head-to-head (if Oregon would even be No. 3) but also is ranked behind that team in at least one of the polls and finished second to that team in the conference standings? Of course, the combined probability of this scenario is about five percent, but at least it gives the playoff lobbyists something to dream about.
More on the Pac-10 Most of the problem lies in one category: scoring margin. Because there is so much parity in the Pac-10, a high percentage of conference games are decided by a touchdown or less -- even the games involving the top teams. Thus, Washington, Oregon and Oregon State have had a difficult time keeping up with Miami, Florida State and Florida in the computer ratings. Want to know what a computer rating would look like if it did not consider scoring margin? Check out the Seattle Times rankings -- the only computer that does not factor in point differential. Washington ranks second, Oregon is fifth and Oregon State is seventh. For those who are curious, the reason the Pac-10 is rated as the best conference by two of these computers is that they rank the teams independently before figuring conference strength. Therefore, these No. 1 rankings can be attributed just as much to the lack of weakness at the bottom of the conference as they can to the strength of the three teams up top. Here's some perspective to the perceived gap between the best of the Pac-10 and the best of the rest. If the teams met on a neutral field this weekend, the Dunkel Index would expect BCS No. 3 Florida State to beat BCS No. 5 Washington by 19 points. The same matchup projects to a 13-point difference in the Massey computer.
At-large updates Brad Edwards is a college football researcher for ESPN and one of the few people who actually understands the BCS. Edwards will provide a weekly analysis of the BCS rankings. |
|