The Fans Speak

Keyword
COLLEGE FOOTBALL
Scoreboard
Schedules
Rankings
Standings
Statistics
Transactions
Injuries
Message Board
Teams
Recruiting
CONFERENCES


SHOP@ESPN.COM
TeamStore
ESPN Auctions
SPORT SECTIONS
Sunday, November 28
Updated: November 29, 11:05 AM ET
 
Where fans come to sound off

ESPN.com

The regular season has drawn to a close, but there's still plenty to talk about. Here's a sampling of what's being said around the country. Listen up -- The Fans Speak

Joe Hamilton
Joe Hamilton and Georgia Tech found themselves in another controversial finish with Georgia.

Talk at the top
Two undefeated teams ranked No. 1 and No. 2 in both polls. Do we really need computers to do this math for us?
Chris Fraker
Blacksburg, Va.

The story of the year has to be Virginia Tech and its dream season. How can anyone say they don't deserve the Sugar Bowl? They took care of business each and every game. In comparison to FSU, Tech soundly defeated their common opponents by almost 26 points while FSU's margain of victory was only 12. Not only does Tech deserve the oppurtunity to face the 'Noles, but they have a great shot at a victory. Tech has a better D and special teams. And on top of that I'd take Michael Vick over Chris Weinke any day. Don't look now 'Noles but Cinderella is wearing her slipper and is ready to dance!
Bruce Johnson
Pembroke Va.

As a fan who used to berate Virginia Tech for its weak schedule, I now find that having anyone else but Tech in the Sugar Bowl is idiotic. They earned the right to play in the Sugar because they dominated their schedule and there is no other team worthy of going to the Sugar Bowl.
Jeff Price
Tallahassee, Fla.

I think it's horrible that the Virginia Tech Hokies are Sugar Bowl bound! It surprised many of us to see a team head to the Sugar Bowl which had such a breeze of a schedule, I think the BCS needs to be reworked once again, and I am not the only one who thinks this way.
Martin Agresti
Miami

As one of the proud Hokies who tore down the goal posts and carried them through downtown Blacksburg, all I have to say is bring on the Seminoles! I'll see you in New Orleans!
Daniel Judge
Blacksburg, Va.

Virginia Tech, any Division I-A team that plays a Division I-AA team should be disqualified from the national championship at the start. Did Boston College look like a Pee-Wee football team to anyone else? My grandmother could have scored those touchdowns.
Jon Burke
Fairport N.Y.

I am a die-hard Tennessee fan, but if Virginia Tech doesn't get the opportunity to play for the national championship then we may as well go back to the old system! If a team can win out, albeit with a less-than-great schedule, and still not get an opportunity to play for it all, then I feel that it sets a bad precedent for the future. The only thing that will be different from the past will be that you must politic in more polls than you used to. Virginia Tech may or may not be the best or second-best team in the country, but they have certainly earned the right to play for the National Championship.
Gerald Branim
Nashville, Tenn.

As much as it pains me to say this as a die-hard 'Husker fan, we do not belong in the national title game. Regardless of our schedule strength, we lost a game and Virginia Tech did not. Plain and simple, we had our chance if we won in Austin but we fumbled it away. I plead to all 'Husker fans not to whine, and just be happy if we win a Big 12 title.
Jeff Krieger
Arlington, Texas

Controversy reigns
Has there ever been a more disgraceful display of officiating in the history of college football than in Saturday's Georgia vs. Ga. Tech game? I have never seen a more flagrant case of officials taking a victory from a team as was the case in this game. It's a travesty!
Eddie Duffey
Carrollton, Ga.

Two years in a row Georgia Tech has beaten Georgia on bad calls from the refs in the final minutes/seconds of the game. How are refs compensated, and are they held accountable for their calls?
M. Ivey
Atlanta

I agree that the fumble at the 2-yard line was not really a fumble, and that Georgia did indeed get a bad call. However, what I haven't heard yet is the horrible decision made by Coach Donnan. The fumble was a disputed call, but the Bulldogs could have easily kneeled, and made a chip shot to win the game. They had to be greedy, and try to run the ball in and win by a touchdown.
Jonathan Sims
Atlanta, Ga.

After once again watching atrocious officiating at the collegiate level, this time during an exciting Georgia-Georgia Tech game, perhaps it is time for the college game to consider instant replay. College refs are consistently inconsistent and downright lousy most of the time. It was a shame to see a great game like UGA-GA Tech this past Saturday decided by incompetent refs. I felt cheated!
P.Tobin
Tyrone, Pa.

That was the worst officiating since the Colorado 5th down!
Mark Provost
Macon, Ga.

BCS banter
It appears that Michigan and Tennessee will be selected as the two at-large BCS teams. Does a one-loss Kansas State team deserve to make it? Maybe. But why is it that everyone believes Michigan is the team that doesn't belong in the BCS? Both Michigan and Tennessee have two losses, one to an unranked team and one to a highly ranked team on the road. Tennessee is clearly benefiting from the BCS's bias towards the SEC. In my opinion, Kansas State and Michigan should be selected.
Brian Roberts
Ann Arbor, Mich.

Marshall University just finished its season 11-0. Just like Florida State, it beat Clemson by three points. Just like Virginia Tech, it hammered Temple. Granted, Marshall's schedule is not among the toughest in the land, but Marshall did what it was supposed to do against such a schedule, i.e., it took care of business by dominating its opponents, finishing in the top 5 in most team statistical categories, including leading the nation in scoring defense by allowing only 104 points (9.13 per game). It should go without saying that Marshall deserves to be one of the participants in the BCS. However, those who vote in the polls, program the computers and devise the BCS rankings have assured themselves that a team that is not a member of one of the "good old boys" conferences realistically cannot advance into the Elite Eight of college football. The game here, my friends, is money, not college football.
Ronald Zane McCann
Hamlin, West Va.

Please send Nebraska to the Fiesta Bowl along with Michigan so we can finally settle the national title dispute in '97.
Dan Neil
Southgate, Mich.

Now that the season is over let's see if the BCS will work better than it did last year! To the BCS officials I say one thing and one thing only. Do the right thing and put Kansas State in the Orange Bowl!
Ryan Krause
Manhattan, Kan.

Another year, another snub by the BCS for Kansas State? If this happens it's a complete sham that the BCS will be unable to explain to any college football fan. Is K-State still paying for the fact they were invited a couple of years ago to the Fiesta Bowl and destroyed a Syracuse team with the great Donovan McNabb? It appears so. If a two-loss Michigan team is selected ahead of K-State, it simply means the BCS is a "Members Only" club that the Wildcats are somehow unworthy to join.
Kurt Mathiasmeier
Orlando

School spirit
Sooners. Bowl Game. 'Nuff said
Chris Davis
Amarillo, Texas

Just wanted to make sure no one missed the big game coming up this weekend. This is the game that the world realizes that Alabama Football is back. If lightning strikes twice then look for a toasted Gator. Roll Tide!
Darren Reese
Dandridge, Tenn.

Everybody loves Hawaii and it's nice that they won some games, but they didn't beat any good teams. I don't think anybody has or ever will mention that they got beat by Washington State (last in the Pac 10). They will lose badly in the Oahu Bowl because they are not the same caliber of team that Oregon State is.
Erik Huffman
Corvallis, Ore.

Florida has got to be upset after this season is over. Talk about running the table. If you would have told me that Florida would have two losses this year and both of them were going to be at the Swamp, I would have laughed at you and told you you're crazy. Is the dynasty of the Swamp over? I don't think so. These Gators are young and I think this year will help them going into next year. They have a lot of young talent that played this year as freshman and sophomores.
Scott Johnson
Jacksonville, Fla.

Heisman hype
If I had a vote -- Joe Hamilton for Heisman. Without him, that Georgia Tech team would be 0-11 with the defense they've got.
Paul Singer
Birmingham, Ala.

Ron Dayne is the obvious Heisman choice, despite Joe Hamilton's solid performance Saturday. Dayne has put up staggering statistics in the toughest football conference in the country. Most importantly, he has lead his team to a conference championship, back-to-back Rose Bowl berths and national ranking of 4th. Put an asterisk next to Dayne's very impressive 1800-plus yards and 19 touchdowns. He has sat out approximately 10 quarters of football due to games being out of reach early. Add 2.5 games worth of statistics to Dayne's totals, and he easily ends up with 2300-plus yards and beats the all-time career rushing record by (not 100, but) 500 yards. Credit Dayne and the Wisconsin program for not running up the score and Dayne's statistics. Many other college programs would have been too tempted to focus on the career rushing record and the Heisman. It's nice to see that kind of class in today's college athletics. That kind of class is what the Heisman is all about. By recognizing and rewarding such class, we might actually help character become the norm again in college sports.
Steve Miller
London, England

Why is Michael Vick not in the running for the Heisman?
John Allen
Blacksburg, Va.

Kudos to Joe Hamilton for a terrific season but congratulations to Ron Dayne for an even better season (yes season -- not just career Jacket fans). Ron Dayne will win the Heisman; only a blown call by those in charge with time running out can save Joe Hamilton this time (not likely to happen again).
Quinn Stein
Great Bend, N.D.

This 'n that
How can Mississippi St. claim they deserve a higher ranking? They play in the SEC and do not play Florida, Tennessee, or Georgia -- three of the better teams in the conference. That's like Purdue not playing Michigan, Wisconsin, and Penn State. What do you think their record would be? Bottom line is they are asked to beat one team and they lose, and the sad thing is they can't even represent the West in the conference championship, when all the power is in the East.
Derek Ridley
Tallahassee, Fla.

How is Mississippi State below the likes of Georgia Tech, Minnesota, and others? They go 9-2 in a strong conference, only lose to 2 teams that have been in the top 25 most of the year, and this is how they are rewarded? No respect, and come next year when they play teams like BYU and Florida, maybe pollsters will begin to give us our due.
Bryce Martin
Fairfield, Ohio

As Colorado finished at 6-5, there are still questions about their bowl situation. After showing what a great team they are -- Nebraska was lucky to win -- they deserve to go to a bowl game. It was the best game in college football this year, and I along with many other CU fans want to see them in the bowl season. Mike Moschetti is a great QB and deserves one last win.
Joe Harder
Boulder, Colo.

Dear Santa,
All I want for Christmas is real football coach for Notre Dame!
James Golab
Birmingham, Mich.

Will Touchdown Jesus let Bob Davie into heaven after leading the Irish to a five and seven?
Barry Crist
West Des Moines, Iowa

After watching the near devastating injury to Travis Henry on Saturday, it brings into focus what is really important. While college football is very dear to most of us, it is just a game and matters very little in the grand scheme of things. Thank goodness the injury wasn't as serious as it first appeared.
Jeff Ramsey
Knoxville, Tenn.

Two Bowls for the Mountain West Conference and C-USA? The lock the other conferences have on the bowl games in conjunction with the bowls' propensity to pick the most marketable schools/conferences is reaon enough to abandon the entire bowl system in favor of a playoff that includes all I-A champions. While some may argue that the bowl system has been good for college football, it is , in reality, only good for about half the participants.
Daniel Foote
Scottsdale, Ariz.

The emotion of the moment
On behalf of everyone here in Aggieland, I would like to extend my deepest gratitude and sincere appreciation to the Texas Longhorns. Your fans have showed a great amount of dignity and class while mourning with us in our time of sorrow. The game was filled with high emotions and thoughts of our fallen 12, and the fans from UT showed grace and respect. The halftime show moved me to tears. Thank you so much for your support and prayers this past week. Our rivalry is forever changed! Gig 'em Ags and Hook 'em Horns!
Courtney Gaskin
College Station, Texas

Congratulations to the Aggies. If there was one game I thought they deserved to win it was this one. Now, on to the Big 12 title game. Hook 'em Horns!
John Kracy
Stephenville, Texas






 ESPN Tools
Email story
 
Most sent
 
Print story