| 
 
| Year | Player | School |  
 1946 | George Connor | Notre Dame |  
 1947 | Joe Steffy | Army |  
 1948 | Bill Fischer | Notre Dame |  
 1949 | Ed Bagdon | Michigan State |  
 1950 | Bob Gain | Kentucky |  
 1951 | Jim Weatherall | Oklahoma |  
 1952 | Dick Modzelewski | Maryland |  
 1953 | J.D. Roberts | Oklahoma |  
 1954 | Bill Brooks | Arkansas |  
 1955 | Calvin Jones | Iowa |  
 1956 | Jim Parker | Ohio State |  
 1957 | Alex Karras | Iowa |  
 1958 | Zeke Smith | Auburn |  
 1959 | Mike McGee | Duke |  
 1960 | Tom Brown | Minnesota |  
 1961 | Merlin Olsen | Utah State |  
 1962 | Bobby Bell | Minnesota |  
 1963 | Scott Appleton | Texas |  
 1964 | Steve DeLong | Tennessee |  
 1965 | Tommy Nobis | Texas |  
 1966 | Loyd Phillips | Arkansas |  
 1967 | Ron Yary | Southern Cal |  
 1968 | Bill Stanfill | Georgia |  
 1969 | Mike Reid | Penn State |  
 1970 | Jim Stillwagon | Ohio State |  
 1971 | Larry Jacobsen | Nebraska |  
 1972 | Rich Glover | Nebraska |  
 1973 | John Hicks | Ohio State |  
 1974 | Randy White | Maryland |  
 1975 | Lee Roy Selmon | Oklahoma |  
 1976 | Ross Browner | Notre Dame |  
 1977 | Brad Shearer | Texas |  
 1978 | Greg Roberts | Oklahoma |  
 1979 | Jim Ritcher | North Carolina State |  
 1980 | Mark May | Pittsburgh |  
 1981 | Dave Rimington | Nebraska |  
 1982 | Dave Rimington | Nebraska |  
 1983 | Dean Steinkuhler | Nebraska |  
 1984 | Bruce Smith | Virginia Tech |  
 1985 | Mike Ruth | Boston College |  
 1986 | Jason Buck | Brigham Young |  
 1987 | Chad Hennings | Air Force |  
 1988 | Tracy Rocker | Auburn |  
 1989 | Mohammed Elewonibi | Brigham Young |  
 1990 | Russell Maryland | Miami |  
 1991 | Steve Emtman | Washington |  
 1992 | Will Shields | Nebraska |  
 1993 | Rob Waldrop | Arizona |  
 1994 | Zach Weigert | Nebraska |  
 1995 | Jonathen Ogden | UCLA |  
 1996 | Orlando Pace | Ohio State |  
 1997 | Aaron Taylor | Nebraska |  
 1998 | Kris Farris | UCLA |  
 
| 1999 | Chris Samuels | Alabama |  
| 2000 | John Henderson | Tennessee |  
| 2001 | Bryant McKinnie | Miami |  
 |  | 
 
 
 |