![]() | |
![]() |
|
| Monday, September 9 Updated: September 17, 8:58 AM ET The Word's Answer Man |
|||||||||||
|
Editor's note: The Answer Man will return on the week of Sept. 30.
Enjoying his time on the campus of Bristol U., ESPN.com's Answer Man found the time to dig back into his mailbag. He's was eager to answer a few questions from ESPN.com users.
In my opinion the problems at Kentucky stem from one thing. NO RESPECT. The players don't respect the coach, the school, the tradition, the fans, or each other. The ultimate responsibility for this lies with the head coach. He recruits the players, sets the rules and is supposed to instill discipline in his program. Why do many in the media hail Tubby Smith as one of the best coaches in college basketball when he has such obvious failings?
Keith,
Tubby running a tight ship? You have to be joking. He's let Fitch, Carruth and others walk all over him for two years now, and its obvious the players don't respect him. When are you and your buddy Vitale ever going to call out Tubby for the poor job he's done since he's been at UK. Whether it's been his poor recruiting, bad coaching and lack of instilling discipline in his players, everyone in the national media seem to ignore this. He's created an atmosphere of apathy in the UK fan base that I've never seen before. If Rick Pitino's players hadn't won him the national title in his first year, he'd been gone by now. It's time for you and others to wake up to what Tubby is really doing at UK, and quit kissing up to him.
Jason,
Hey Answer Man,
Daniel,
Dan Monson decided to stay at Minnesota, instead of taking the job at Washington. I'm the biggest Minnesota fan in the state of Nebraska, and I'm curious, does he think he has a really good team coming in? Can the incoming freshman class that includes Aloiu Kane and Stanley Gaines contribute immediately? Will Minnesota take the next step and become a national powerhouse like they one were until the scandal hit their program? With Rick Rickert, Kevin Burleson, Jerry Holman, and Ben Johnson ... is this going to be another disappointing year like last year or will be a sweet 16 or great 8? Monson does think he has a good team, not great. He knows this team is young and inexperienced at a few key positions. But they've got the potential to rise up in a wide-open Big Ten. Michigan State and Indiana should be the favorites with Wisconsin nipping at them for third. But Minnesota has a legit chance to challenge the Badgers and be the fourth-place team in this rebuilding league. Johnson played well on the Big 10 tour and Rickert should put together an all-American season. But point guard will be a question and winning on the road hasn't been so easy for this squad, yet. Get to the tournament first before any talk of Sweet 16 or Elite Eight begins in Minneapolis.
Great column, the info you provide for all college hoops junkies is fantastic. First off I'd like to know your opinion on the upcoming season for the Temple Owls, I have been a huge fan of John Chaney and his program. Now I know that they lost a lot in Lynn Greer and Kevin Lyde, but they have a super player in David Hawkins. Do you see him in the mold of a Mark Macon, Eddie Jones, Aaron McKie-type player? Is this year one of the Elite Eight runs for Temple? Second I have read your responses to some questions you answered and yes I agree with you that the Arizona Wildcats are not a lock for the Final Four, but who is? Thats why they play the games, however compared to most of the top teams this year they have to be put in the Final Four category. Let me know how you feel about their upcoming season as well. Keep up the good work. Thanks
Peter, In the September 3 answers column you made the statement, "If you're talking true mid-major (and not Gonzaga) then I don't think it will happen." I'm sure you're listening to Mark Few and not the facts of the university. Perhaps you meant the performance of the GU basketball team since the early 90's? They are big-time in that department. But far from being a major it's just the opposite. They are the archetype mid-major, in the WCC, a league that is the archetype mid-major conference. The WCC consistently ranks 15th and they battle all the NCAA and large university prejudices just like any other mid-major. Here are some stats from fall enrollment 1999. The university has had some increase since than, but nothing to bring it within miles of a major university in money, crowd attendance and enrollment. I'm not sure what guidelines you're using, but it would be interesting to know. Really, I'd call GU a very nice small university.
Gonzaga's 1999 fall enrollment is 4,435, broken out as follows: Jane Oddrib Spokane, Wash. Wow, Jane, very informative. But here's my take on a mid-major. It's not about the size. If it was then schools like Northwestern would be mid-majors, too. Outside of the big six conferences (ACC, Big Ten, Big East, Big 12, SEC and Pac-10), a mid-major is a school that can't get a made-for-TV television game, doesn't recruit top 100 players or get those type of transfers, can't win a game in the NCAA Tournament, and doesn't register on the national stage. Gonzaga plays in a mid-major conference in the WCC, but the Zags aren't mid-major in my book. Pepperdine is on the cusp of breaking through, too. But the Waves still need to win more and the networks aren't setting up games for them, either. If the networks (ESPN, CBS or Fox) aren't calling then you know where you stand. That's the reality of today's college basketball.
Andy, Northern Iowa must be high on the Valley's radar because they were included in the Bracket Buster. Commissioner Doug Elgin wanted four teams that could compete for the title in the event and chose Southern Illinois, Creighton, Illinois State and Northern Iowa. Obviously, beating Iowa helped their regional and national profile. Godfread is a big man that is still developing and didn't mesh with Majerus. Not sure on Schmit or Schneiderman, but Crawford was a can't-miss in the MAC. Opposing coaches were applauding his departure because they knew he was trouble for them to defend had he returned to Bowling Green. If the transfers are all legit then Northern Iowa could be a tough out this season, but a favorite in 2003-04.
Andy! Can you please explain to me why the NCAA is taking so long in dealing the UofM Wolverines sanctions/punishment and how harsh do you think the punishment will be. It seems to me like if a school like UNLV had this happen to them, the NCAA would have acted swiftly and shut the program down. I understand UofM's history isn't tainted like UNLVs, but these allegations are far worse than anything UNLV did (to my knowledge). ... I don't get it?
Vas
Vas,
Manhattan College basketball gets no respect for being the best team in New York City. Last season the Jaspers beat the best of the best in NYC, St. John's being the best. At the point we were headed to the Tournament with an at-large bid if we went undefeated in the MAAC. But obviously that didn't happen. Is this the year Manhattan finally gets the respect it deserves. After two successful years under Bobby Gonzolez, it seems as though this is the year we breakout. Last year's MAAC leading scorer, Luis Flores, is back as well as Dave Holmes and Jared Johnson. We have also brought in New Hamshire's high school player of the year, a 7-footer from Europe, and two very good guards, one from rice and one for mass. Our schedule also gives us the opportunity to play such teams as St. John's, North Carolina and Louisville. Is the the year Manhattan makes some noise in college basketball? Gonzolez would like to think so. But the reality is Manhattan would have had a hard time getting an at-large berth, just by beating St. John's and running the table in the MAAC. A team from the MAAC is at a disadvantage because its power rating will plummet when it plays teams in its league. Manhattan has to worry about winning the MAAC tournament first before an at-large berth. And that means they can't tire in March. The Jaspers are a potential league favorite but they need to get a better seed going into the tournament and that means winning road games in the league in January and early February. Flores is the star of the team and possibly the league but he needs help. Gonzolez has done a nice job recruiting and now he's got to coach this team to the tournament. The talent is in place.
Hey Andy, Yes. Amaker is doing a great job in state and nationally getting players to commit to Michigan, even under a cloud of potential sanctions. But he's still not ahead of Michigan State regionally or nationally. That will take time. It might not happen under Izzo and that's not all that bad. There are plenty of players in the state of Michigan and the Wolverines still have a national name to grab top 50 talent from the South, Southwest, West or Northeast. Amaker is patient and Wolverines fans must be, too, if Michigan is going to get through its toughest basketball period in its history. Andy Katz is a senior writer at ESPN.com. He answers questions on college basketball weekly. |
|
||||||||||