Weekly Word

Keyword
M COLLEGE BB
Scores
Schedules
Rankings
Standings
Statistics
Transactions
Teams
Players
Recruiting
Message Board
CONFERENCES


ESPN MALL
TeamStore
ESPN Auctions
SPORT SECTIONS
Friday, November 22
Updated: November 23, 5:48 PM ET
 
Keeping kids in-state key to building programs

By Andy Katz
ESPN.com

Before he was on the cover of Sports Illustrated and courting agents as a senior in high school, Ohio State had an "in" with LeBron James. Now, this was way back when James was a little-known freshman. But the plan, as silly as it seems now, was to get James to sign a national letter of intent to play basketball for the Buckeyes.

The Buckeyes were all over James, as much as a school could be while recruiting in-state, 15-year-olds. They sent him mail when they were supposed to, made the calls when they were allowed to, but more than anything, they were close enough for James to come see the Buckeyes play.

Ivan Harris
Ivan Harris stayed close to home by signing with Ohio State ...

And it wasn't just James. Ivan Harris, he of Springfield, Ohio, was also on Ohio State's radar. And in a perfect Buckeye word, the pair would sign with Ohio State during the fall of 2002 when they were seniors.

Well, the Buckeyes got a commitment and signature on a national letter of intent from Harris last week. As for James? Well, he lists Ohio State as one of his five schools, but only a fool still thinks he'll be in college, rather than the NBA next season.

But the fact remains, Ohio State initially had a chance to pull off an in-state coup with both players. And it shouldn't come as a surprise. The Buckeyes got one of the two, just like Mississippi State got the commitments from its two best players in the state (Jackie Butler committed and Travis Outlaw signed); Wisconsin from its top player (Brian Butch); and Cal from the best in the state (Leon Powe).

The trend to stay home is catching on with high school phenoms. The trend, however, begins with players taking advantage of unofficial visits, getting to know the staff and the school on your own terms rather than the NCAAs of one visit late in the junior season, or the one call a week in the months beyond.

While Arizona, Duke, Kansas and Oklahoma filled their classes out of state with some of the top talent, nearly half of the top talent stayed home. Ten of the top 25 signed with a school in state, and only two of the top 25 aren't committed -- James and Brandon Bass of Baton Rouge, La. Bass could still end up at LSU, and even the committed James Lang of Birmingham isn't a lock for Louisville because he could choose to go to the draft. The other committed player who didn't sign during the week-long, early-signing period that concluded Wednesday, is Charlie Villanueva of Blair Academy (N.J.). He committed but didn't sign with Illinois, because he's still waiting to see where he would be in the NBA draft.

"It's becoming harder to go into someone's state and get their kids," Ohio State coach Jim O'Brien said. "It's very important to get the best players in the state. When we first got here, Michigan State got Andre Hutson, A.J. Granger, Doug Davis and Adam Wolfe from the state. Now they recruited Ivan hard, but we got him. The toughest competition for us in the state is usually Cincinnati and Xavier."

Again, a lot of what sways a potential recruit's decision-making process, has to do with access.

Brian Butch
... so did 7-foot Brian Butch, who inked with Wisconsin.

O'Brien said a number of coaches are encouraging the underclassmen to make a lot of visits on their own. They want them to come to practice, a football game, or basketball game, and get as familiar with the campus much as they can under the rules. If the player is local, he can drive down and come around as much as he wants, as long as it's not during a dead recruiting period.

"You get a relationship that way that you can't have with a player who is further away," O'Brien said. "Ivan was up here a load of times. He'd walk into the arena and people would know him. He was only 45 minutes away."

Leon Powe, a top talent out of California, came to games at Cal from his freshman year on at Oakland Tech -- in the Bears' backyard. The only way Powe's presence on campus was going to backfire on Cal coach Ben Braun was if there was a poor relationship.

"We have the word 'California' on our uniform, so we have to continue to get the local talent. But we can't only recruit California," Braun said.

That's obvious. Programs can't rely strictly in-state to survive. Mississippi State just happened to get a year when two of the best players in the country were from Mississippi.

"It's an advantage, but there are still five other SEC schools within a three-hour radius of any kid in Mississippi," Mississippi State coach Rick Stansbury said. "When we got Erick Dampier to stay home, it showed that you could have a local kid stay here and go to the Final Four (in 1996). But we're not going to take a kid if he doesn't fit.

"The best player in the state, isn't always best for your program. There weren't point guards here this year, so that's why we went out of state (to New York to get Gary Ervin). But most of the kids in Mississippi are going to be us and somebody else recruiting them."

Getting a local kid isn't the only answer, but it can ease any pain on alumni if the player is good enough to play at your school and you lock him up. That's why Wake Forest almost had to get Chris Paul of nearby Clemons, N.C. Three of the four players Wake signed are from North Carolina.

"It's not a must, but it helps," Wake Forest coach Skip Prosser said. "You can't be afraid to recruit against the big in-state school, either. We weren't at Xavier. But we have something different here because we're a small, private school in the middle of the best conference in the country."

But Wisconsin coach Bo Ryan wants to make it clear that 7-foot Brian Butch of Appleton, Wis., didn't choose Wisconsin just because he wanted to stay home. Ryan says Butch chose Wisconsin because of the program, not just the proximity.

"Everybody keeps saying that it's great that he stayed home, but wait a second," Ryan said. "He lives in Wisconsin and he felt good about our program. He didn't just choose us because we're near his home. We saw him as a type of player we'd love to have because he dove on the floor the first time we saw him and you don't see that from big men all the time."

And if Butch didn't choose Wisconsin and went to, say, North Carolina? The Badgers would have heard about it through fan message boards, but that doesn't mean they would be toast in competing for the Big Ten title.

The same is true down in the Bayou where Bass is deciding among LSU, Connecticut and Mississippi State. If LSU coach John Brady doesn't land Bass, it won't be because he didn't try to keep one of the top local players in the state (Lisbon's small forward Vakeaton Wafer chose Florida State).

"We've gotten the local kid like Stromile Swift and sometimes you're going to miss," Brady said. "We got Tack Minor out of Houston, does that mean that's bad for Texas? No. It's overblown a bit. It's not where they're from, but are they good enough.

"If they're all leaving Louisiana and, specifically Baton Rouge, then that's one thing. Chris Duhon left Louisiana for Duke, but Stromile stayed here. I wish I could get them all but you don't."

But one out of two ain't bad. Just ask the Buckeyes.

Billy Edelin
Billy Edelin's punishment seems a little extreme, but other suspended players only have themselves to blame.
Suspended players know better
Syracuse's Billy Edelin is the exception. Getting dinged for 12 games for playing in an unsanctioned men's league during the 2001-02 school year when he wasn't a Syracuse student doesn't make any sense.

The rest of the players getting suspended only have themselves and their college's athletic staffs to blame.

The rule governing college basketball players is pretty simple, and while it's hard to agree with it in principle, it's still a rule. Play in an unsanctioned summer league and the player is going to end up sitting games. Players know it. Coaches know it. That's why it shouldn't come as a shock when the players are sitting at the beginning of the season. Players like Kentucky's Erik Daniels, Georgia's Chris Daniels, and Illinois' Brian Cook and Jerrance Howard, don't have an excuse.

The NCAA made only one exception, and that was for North Carolina's Will Johnson and Jonathan Holmes, who played in a 3-on-3 tourney, benefiting cancer research.

"We went over the rules with our guys, we laid it out there," Illinois coach Bill Self said. "But Brian wasn't there. He was at Nike camp at the time we told everyone in July. They said there was a tournament in Peoria. We said we would check on it, but we didn't say, 'Don't do it.'

"It was bad communication. It's tough to penalize these guys for playing basketball. "We say you shouldn't do it, but if there is a tournament where they're scoring and keeping time, it's hard for me to believe that kids aren't playing in these things all over the country. The reason they don't get reported is not all of them are in the paper. This is a tough rule to enforce. But you could argue that the kids have to use better judgment."

The number of suspensions in 2002 should serve as a wakeup call for next summer, or else the same thing could occur at the beginning of next season.

As for Austin ...
Mississippi State coach Rick Stansbury is working with two game plans in lieu of Mario Austin's ongoing eligibility issues.

Plan A: Austin's eligibility is cleared up, he returns to the SEC defending champs by the end of the month, and the Bulldogs have their best inside scorer while they get ready for their title defense.

Plan B: Austin remains on the bench through a light early non-conference schedule. And, without the 16.1 points and 7.6 rebounds he provided last season, MSU must get a sudden surge from junior Lincoln Smith (2.3 ppg) and 7-foot sophomore Marcus Campbell (2.8 ppg).

McNeese State, Jacksonville, Alabama A&M, Jackson State and Louisiana Tech shouldn't pose much problems for the Bulldogs, who'll become a perimeter-oriented team that might seem more predictable. But Xavier (Dec. 14) at Madison Square Garden will be a tough night without Austin to go up against David West down low.

The Bulldogs are a top 15 team with Austin. And Austin's eligibility questions are absurd on the surface with his initial eligibility being called into question two years after he was certified. Sources say he's not being held out because of any questions over whether he signed with an agent or if he was eligible, even though he missed three full weeks of school when he left campus (taking all his belongings) and planned on entering the NBA draft last April. He returned and, apparently, had to make up the work to remain eligible.

The NCAA puts a school like Mississippi State in a bad position because the NCAA isn't technically suspending him. Instead, the school is holding him out of games as a precautionary measure. The school isn't saying if he's practicing right now, either. But if the Bulldogs play him, and the NCAA rules that he is in fact ineligible, then they can be subject to forfeiting games.

If Austin's situation drags on too long, don't be surprised if the school pushes to play Austin and take its chances. The Bulldogs don't want to get hung up in a legal battle over his eligibility while the season starts to get away from them. Mississippi State can get through the non-conference without Austin, save a game against Xavier and Oklahoma in New Orleans, but the Bulldogs can't expect to stay with Alabama and LSU without Austin in the SEC West.

Weekly Word

  • Montana coach Pat Kennedy checked in this week from Missoula, Mont. He was practically humming about the big sky, the warmer weather in Montana -- at least warmer than Chicago (48 and sunny to 30 degrees and cloudy) -- his recruiting class and the overall collegiate atmosphere. The Grizzlies were getting ready for the football game Saturday against rival Montana State and the campus was abuzz. "This reminds of Florida State," Kennedy said. "This is a great college town." Kennedy is hoping to upgrade the talent at Montana -- quickly. He's got Saint Louis 6-9 forward John Seyfert, a native of Montana, sitting out this season. He also added an athletic recruiting class that could change the style of play with 6-2 Roy Booker (Allen County CC in Kansas), 6-7 Kamaar Davis (Sheridan JC in Wyo.) and 6-5 Jon Wilkins (Northeastern Colorado JC) The Grizzlies will find it tough in the Big Sky to get past Eastern Washington, Weber State and Montana State, and losing forward Brent Cummings to a back injury didn't help the situation. Playing in the Great Alaska Shootout, Gonzaga, at Washington State and in Stanford's tournament could make for a rough transition for Kennedy to Big Sky country. "There's quite a tradition of coaches here that makes it quite an interesting little place," Kennedy said.

  • Kent State's Antonio Gates is a bit miffed that no one is even talking about the Golden Flashes in the MAC, let alone the national discussion. Everything has been about Ohio and Ball State in the MAC, Stan Heath at Arkansas, but not much made about the team that went to the Elite Eight last season. "No one mentions the defending champs," Gates said. "If people want to say we can't compete then so be it. We know we're the defending MAC champs. Defense and rebounding got us this far and we're going to approach everything the same way." The reason for the lack of love is the lack of Trevor Huffman. Whether junior Eric Haut or freshman DeAndre Haynes can replace Huffman at the point will be key. Neither will be asked to score 16 a game like Huffman, but they've got to give defenses reasons to guard them or else Gates will get too much attention on the wing. Gates has to play power forward for these Golden Flashes, but he'll be facing the basket quite a bit. And can Ohio or Ball State do what Kent State did and go 17-1? "It's tough, real tough," Gates said. "I don't care if it's the ACC or the Big Ten, that's tough to do in a league. It's hard to go to Marshall, to Ball State, to Ohio and win."

  • Wake Forest is finally healthy for the first time since practice started. The Demon Deacons will have a complete team when the season starts this weekend and that means Josh Howard has to be the team's go-to player and freshmen Eric Williams must be a power presence in the post.

  • Cal is leaning on junior A.J. Diggs and freshman Richard Midgley to play the point until senior guard Donte Smith gets healthy. The position was going to be in flux once senior Shantay Legans transferred to Fresno State in September. Cal coach Ben Braun isn't as concerned about the point as he is help for 6-10 sophomore Amit Tamir inside. Gabriel Hughes is coming off a herniated disc and isn't at full strength. Freshmen 6-8 David Paris or 6-10 Rod Benson must play significant minutes for the Bears to keep up with not just Pac-10 teams in the post.

  • Ohio State is content to keep Brandon Fuss-Cheatham at the point, although coach Jim O'Brien is on him about improving his perimeter shooting. When Fuss-Cheatham is out of the game, O'Brien will move Brent Darby to the point. Meanwhile, the Buckeyes aren't complaining about their now more mature frontcourt with sophomore Terence Dials, junior Velimir Radinovic, junior Zach Williams and O'Brien's sleeper, 6-6 JC transfer Shun Jenkins -- perhaps the most physically mature and aggressive newcomer the Buckeyes have had the past two years.

  • The NCAA has to put a stop to the exhibition games, unless they are against non-Division I teams, international, the Harlem Globetrotters or controlled scrimmages. These games against AAU or summer-league sponsored teams are a joke. They are a payoff, nothing more and nothing less. Every coach ESPN.com talked to on the subject said they only play the games because they got, or are getting, a player from these programs in Louisiana, Michigan, Texas, Minnesota, New York and on and on. No one would complain if the NCAA put an end to this loophole. If a "all-star" travel team gets $25,000 to play an exhibition game, it is nothing more than an unofficial way to make a thank you payment. If the NCAA doesn't want to cancel them, it must put a cap on paying these teams. Say, $5,000 ... just to put some sanity in the process.

  • Lost amid the signings this week was one out of the University of San Francisco. The Dons announced they had signed 6-9 sophomore forward Julian Sensley out of Los Angeles City College. This is the same Sensley who declared for the draft, but didn't get a sniff after an embarrassingly poor performance at the Chicago pre-draft camp. He could still go to school because he was never an eligible college student. He went to Cal, Iona and Fresno State before ever getting eligible. If he ever makes it onto the court at USF it would be quite a turnaround for a player who was once considered one of the top five forwards in his recruiting class.

  • Former Fresno State coach Jerry Tarkanian made his rounds to Marquette, Illinois and Iowa State during October and left more impressed with Cyclones JC transfer guard Tim Barnes. He said he might have been the best scoring guard of the bunch. Barnes and Jake Sullivan could form one of the more unheralded backcourts in the Big 12.

  • LSU coach John Brady is concerned about his team's poor shooting. The Tigers were 3 for 18 and 4 for 21 on 3s in two exhibitions. Torris Bright was 1 for 14, and Antonio Hudson was 0 for 7. "If that continues we won't overcome that," Brady said. Brady kept likely starting forward Shawnson Johnson out of the first exhibition because he didn't adhere to a team dress code policy. But he scored 13 points and grabbed 13 rebounds in the second exhibition. "I'll take those numbers every night," Brady said.

  • Remember the name Taylor Coppenwrath. Vermont truly believes the 6-8 sophomore has a legit shot to be an NBA player. Coppenwrath shoots with range, can put the ball on the court and is a potential double-double player after averaging 16.6 points and 7 rebounds a game last season.

  • The word out of the NABC Classic was about Wisconsin's point-guard play. The much-maligned Badger playmakers -- Freddie Owens and Devin Harris -- weren't weak links (no turnovers against Northern Illinois). Meanwhile, Wisconsin coach Bo Ryan is keeping the trend Dick Bennett started by playing the other state Division I schools with back-to-back games against Ryan's former team, Wisconsin-Milwaukee, and then UW-Green Bay.

  • Charlotte's sleeper is 6-8 freshman Curtis Withers. Bobby Lutz is banking on him playing major minutes from the outset after he went 4 for 9, grabbed 7 rebounds and had four assists and no turnovers in an exhibition game. The 49ers are in a transition season but should still finish in the top four in the American Division in Conference USA.

  • Clemson lost reserve forward Tomas Nagys for eight games for making phone calls totaling $553.20 on the university's bill, something the basketball staff should have been aware of, according to the penalty. The Tigers could ill afford any more issues with a tenuous roster. The Tigers still don't know how many games Israeli Ori Ichaki will miss. He could sit as many as eight, like fellow countryman Izchak Ohanon at Saint Louis, for playing with pros in Israel. The Tigers were already hit hard in the offseason when guard Tony Stockman transferred to Ohio State and guard Dwon Clifton transferred to UNC Greensboro. Clemson is also playing away from their home court while Littljohn Coliseum is being renovated. The Tigers will play eight of the first nine games in Anderson, S.C. The target date for completion is early January for the Duke game (Jan. 5). Clemson finished 13-17 overall last season, 4-12 in the ACC. The league is wide open, giving the Tigers hope to move up in what is a critical season for the program.

  • Boston University coach Dennis Wolff was disappointed with the 61-57 loss to Stanford in the opening round of the Preseason NIT on Monday night. But here's the rub on that obvious statement: He should be. The Terriers should have beaten Stanford in Palo Alto. He knows it and the fact that they were a few shots away from pulling away in the first half and then, perhaps, changing the second half, means the Terriers are better than anyone imagined. It also means that the Terriers could be a spoiler for a team like Ohio that comes calling Dec. 13, in a game that the Bobcats might haunt them later when and if they're trying to be an at-large team. BU also gets George Washington at home, giving an America East team two home games against a high-level MAC school and a mid-level A-10 school -- something that doesn't happen often in the America East. "To separate your program you've got to play games like Stanford and the ones we've got here at home," Wolff said. "We went in as a 16 seed last season and went against a No. 1 in Cincinnati. Maybe if we get in this will help us (get a better seed). For a team like us, mental toughness is the difference. We're not here for moral victories. I don't want people to say, 'We saw you on ESPN and boy what a great job.' We lost and we should have won. Maybe Mike (Montgomery of Stanford) doesn't feel that way but we made enough plays to win and it was a two-point game with a minute to go."

  • Oregon averaged 133 points in two exhibition games and the Ducks really believe that averaging over 90 points and leading the nation in scoring isn't out of the question.

    Andy Katz is a senior writer at ESPN.com. His Weekly Word on college basketball is updated Fridays throughout the year.









  •  More from ESPN...
    James remains free-agent as early signing period ends
    Colleges recruiters didn't ...

    Have a question for the Weekly Word?
    Have a question about the ...

    Missed the Word?
    Catch up on college hoops ...

    Division I basketball coaching changes
    Here's a rundown of coaching ...

    Andy Katz Archive

     ESPN Tools
    Email story
     
    Most sent
     
    Print story
     
    Daily email