Keyword
MLB
  Scores
  Schedules
  Standings
  Statistics
  Transactions
  Injuries
  Players
  Message Board
  Minor Leagues
  MLB en espaņol


 
The Roster
  Peter Gammons
  Joe Morgan
  Rob Neyer
  Jayson Stark
 
Fantasy
  Player News
  Correspondents
 
Broadcast
  ESPN Radio
  Video Highlights
  Audio Highlights
 
SportsMall
  Shop@ESPN.com
  NikeTown
  TeamStore


Sport Sections

Tuesday, May 29
Feedback: Boles lacked experience



John Boles
Boles
We asked you if the Marlins made the right decision when they fired John Boles on Monday. Most ESPN.com users agreed that it's easier to fire a manager than the players. Some put the blame on relief pitcher Dan Miceli's shoulders.

Here's a sample of what you had to say:

No other choice
I think that it's a smart move. As Miceli said, it's just not his opinion but everyone else's as well. When you have a young ballclub, they need an experienced coach that can prepare them for the majors.

Scott
Boca Raton, Fla.


I think he lost any respect he may have had with his team when he did not back them during the Mets series. After (Cliff) Floyd got hit, he should have made a point to the umpires since Bobby Valentine had basically said they were going to throw at Floyd. However, he just sat there and did nothing. Good man, but it was time for him to go.

Lenny
Miami, Fla.


Great move by the Marlins' management. Having anyone else in there is a good move. Whenever I watched Marlins games, I always wondered what Boles was up to.

Brent Friesen
Mission, B.C.


This was going to happen sooner or later. Boles is too timid to be a good manager, and rarely ever argues calls – even if they are obviously wrong. I never thought he was qualified to do the job.

Rob Hingston
Miami, Fla.


The firing is probably justified in that he is no longer in "charge" of the team. Obviously, Miceli's criticism must have had some weight, or Boles would still be the manager.

Brian M. Mac Kenzie
Clifton Park, N.Y.


If a team fails to perform or win, the first guy to take the fall is the manager. If the team had lost respect for the manager, a change had to be made. Tony Perez is one of the best men in baseball and would be a great manager if he decides to manage full-time.

Jeff Christner
Indianapolis, IN


The Marlins have all the pieces of the puzzle, minus a team leader. Tony Perez will bring the guidance to their lineup, one which is already coming into its own.

Raj Trivedi
San Diego, Calif.


John Boles was in charge of player development before becoming the "Head Fish." He is not the right guy to take this team to the next level better known as the playoffs. He was a nice guy which is not always a good attribute for a manager – especially when your team needs to be fired up.

Larry Walansky
Brooklyn, N.Y.


Who's really in charge?
I wonder if Miceli blames his inability to get anyone out on John Boles. With an ERA of over six, maybe he should try to get an out before he runs his mouth about his manager. I guess if the manager has major league experience, Miceli will pitch better.

Steven Rasmussen
Miami, Fla.


The Marlins should have held a second news conference after the firing of John Boles. Dave Dombrowski should have called Dan Miceli and the rest of the pitching staff out on the carpet. Miceli needs to put up or shut up!

Curt Hitchens
Rocky Face, Ga.


Miceli said he would like to play for a winning team. This from a guy who has been awful this season. Hey Miceli, the fans would like a winner in the bullpen. What can we do? Any ideas?

Ralph Varela
Miami Springs, Fla.


If the merchandise stinks, I guess you fire the store manager?

Todd Nonnenberg
Hoboken, N.J.


A journeyman relief pitcher such as Miceli might want to keep his thoughts to himself because he can be replaced just as easily as Boles.

Jerry Martin
Oceanside, Calif.





 ESPN Tools
Email story
 
Most sent stories