| Year | Result | MVP | 
| 1998 | New York (AL) 4, San Diego (NL) 0 | Scott Brosius | 
| 1997 | Florida (NL) 4, Cleveland (AL) 3 | Livan Hernandez | 
| 1996 | New York (AL) 4, Atlanta (NL) 2 | John Wetteland | 
| 1995 | Atlanta (NL) 4, Cleveland (AL) 2 | Tom Glavine | 
| 1994 | Series cancelled |  | 
| 1993 | Toronto (AL) 4, Philadelphia (NL) 2 | Paul Molitor | 
| 1992 | Toronto (AL) 4, Atlanta (NL) 2 | Pat Borders | 
| 1991 | Minnesota (AL) 4, Atlanta (NL) 3 | Jack Morris | 
| 1990 | Cincinnati (NL) 4, Oakland (AL) 0 | Jose Rijo | 
| 1989 | Oakland (AL) 4, San Francisco (NL) 0 | Dave Stewart | 
| 1988 | Los Angeles (NL) 4, Oakland (AL) 1 | Orel Hershiser | 
| 1987 | Minnesota (AL) 4, St. Louis (NL) 3 | Frank Viola | 
| 1986 | New York (NL) 4, Boston (AL) 3 | Ray Knight | 
| 1985 | Kansas City (AL) 4, St. Louis (NL) 3 | Bret Saberhagen | 
| 1984 | Detroit (AL) 4, San Diego (NL) 1 | Alan Trammell | 
| 1983 | Baltimore (AL) 4, Philadelphia (NL) 1 | Rick Dempsey | 
| 1982 | St. Louis (NL) 4, Milwaukee (AL) 3 | Darrell Porter | 
 
| 1981 | Los Angeles (NL) 4, New York (AL) 2 | Ron Cey, Pedro Guerrero, Steve Yeager | 
| 1980 | Philadephia (NL) 4, Kansas City (AL) 2 | Mike Schmidt | 
| 1979 | Pittsburgh (NL) 4, Baltimore (AL) 3 | Willie Stargell | 
| 1978 | New York (AL) 4, Los Angeles (NL) 2 | Bucky Dent | 
| 1977 | New York (AL) 4, Los Angeles (NL) 2 | Reggie Jackson | 
| 1976 | Cincinnati (NL) 4, New York (AL) 0 | Johnny Bench | 
| 1975 | Cincinnati (NL) 4, Boston (AL) 3 | Pete Rose | 
| 1974 | Oakland (AL) 4, Los Angeles (NL) 1 | Rollie Fingers | 
| 1973 | Oakland (AL) 4, New York (NL) 3 | Reggie Jackson | 
| 1972 | Oakland (AL) 4, Cincinnati (NL) 3 | Gene Tenace | 
| 1971 | Pittsburgh (NL) 4, Baltimore (AL) 3 | Roberto Clemente | 
| 1970 | Baltimore (AL) 4, Cincinnati (NL) 1 | Brooks Robinson | 
| 1969 | New York (NL) 4, Baltimore (AL) 1 | Donn Clendenon | 
| 1968 | Detroit (AL) 4, St. Louis (NL) 3 | Mickey Lolich | 
| 1967 | St. Louis (NL) 4, Boston (AL) 3 | Bob Gibson | 
| 1966 | Baltimore (AL) 4, Los Angeles (NL) 0 | Frank Robinson | 
| 1965 | Los Angeles (NL) 4, Minnesota (AL) 3 | Sandy Koufax | 
| 1964 | St. Louis (NL) 4, New York AL (3) | Bob Gibson | 
| 1963 | Los Angeles (NL) 4, New York (AL) 0 | Sandy Koufax | 
| 1962 | New York (AL) 4, San Francisco (NL) 3 | Ralph Terry | 
| 1961 | New York (AL) 4, Cincinnati (NL) 1 | Whitey Ford | 
| 1960 | Pittsburgh (NL) 4, New York (AL) 3 | Bobby Richardson (N.Y.) | 
| 1959 | Los Angeles (NL) 4, Chicago (AL) 2 | Larry Sherry | 
| 1958 | New York (AL) 4, Milwaukee (NL) 3 | Bob Turley | 
| 1957 | Milwaukee (NL) 4, New York (AL) 3 | Lew Burdette | 
| 1956 | New York (AL) 4, Brooklyn (NL) 3 | Don Larsen | 
| 1955 | Brooklyn (NL) 4, New York(AL) 3 | Johnny Podres | 
| 1954 | New York (NL) 4, Cleveland (AL) 0 |  | 
| 1953 | New York (AL) 4, Brooklyn (NL) 2 |  | 
| 1952 | New York (AL) 4, Brooklyn (NL) 3 |  | 
| 1951 | New York (AL) 4, New York (NL) 2 |  | 
| 1950 | New York (AL) 4, Philadelphia (NL) 0 |  | 
| 1949 | New York (AL) 4, Brooklyn (NL) 1 |  | 
| 1948 | Cleveland (AL) 4, Boston (NL) 2 |  | 
| 1947 | New York (AL) 4, Brooklyn (NL) 3 |  | 
| 1946 | St. Louis (NL) 4, Bosotn (AL) 3 |  | 
| 1945 | Detroit (AL) 4, Chicago (NL) 3 |  | 
| 1944 | St. Louis (NL) 4, St. Louis (AL) 2 |  | 
| 1943 | New York (AL) 4, St. Louis (NL) 1 |  | 
| 1942 | St. Louis (NL) 4, New York (AL) 1 |  | 
| 1941 | New York (AL) 4, Brooklyn (NL) 1 |  | 
| 1940 | Cincinnati (NL) 4, Detroit (AL) 3 |  | 
| 1939 | New York (AL) 4, Cincinnati (NL) 0 |  | 
| 1938 | New York (AL) 4, Chicago (NL) 0 |  | 
| 1937 | New York (AL) 4, New York (NL) 1 |  | 
| 1936 | New York (AL) 4, New York (NL) 2 |  | 
| 1935 | Detroit (AL) 4, Chicago (NL) 2 |  | 
| 1934 | St. Louis (NL) 4, Detroit (AL) 3 |  | 
| 1933 | New York (NL) 4, Washington (AL) 1 |  | 
| 1932 | New York (AL) 4, Chicago (NL) 0 |  | 
| 1931 | St. Louis (NL) 4, Philadelphia (AL) 3 |  | 
| 1930 | Philadelphia (AL) 4, St. Louis (NL) 2 |  | 
| 1929 | Philadelphia (AL) 4, Chicago (NL) 1 |  | 
| 1928 | New York (AL) 4, St. Louis (NL) 0 |  | 
| 1927 | New York (AL) 4, Pittsburgh (NL) 0 |  | 
| 1926 | St. Louis (NL) 4, New York (AL) 3 |  | 
| 1925 | Pittsburgh (NL) 4, Washington (AL) 3 |  | 
| 1924 | Washington (AL) 4, New York (NL) 3 |  | 
| 1923 | New York (AL) 4, New York (NL) 2 |  | 
| 1922 | New York (NL) 4, New York (AL) 0 |  | 
| 1921 | New York (NL) 5, New York (AL) 3 |  | 
| 1920 | Cleveland (AL) 5, Brooklyn (NL) 2 |  | 
| 1919 | Cincinnati (NL) 5, Chicago (AL) 3 |  | 
| 1918 | Boston (AL) 4, Chicago (NL) 2 |  | 
| 1917 | Chicago (AL) 4, New York (NL) 2 |  | 
| 1916 | Boston (AL) 4, Brooklyn (NL) 1 |  | 
| 1915 | Boston (AL) 4, Philadelphia (NL) 1 |  | 
| 1914 | Boston (NL) 4, Philadelphia (AL) 0 |  | 
| 1913 | Philadelphia (AL) 4, New York (NL) 1 |  | 
| 1912 | Boston (AL) 4, New York (NL) 3 |  | 
| 1911 | Philadelphia (AL) 4, New York (NL) 2 |  | 
| 1910 | Philadelphia (AL) 4, Chicago (NL) 1 |  | 
| 1909 | Pittsburgh (NL) 4, Detroit (AL) 3 |  | 
| 1908 | Chicago (NL) 4, Detroit (AL) 1 |  | 
| 1907 | Chicago (NL) 4, Detroit (AL) 0 |  | 
| 1906 | Chicago (AL) 4, Chicago (NL) 2 |  | 
| 1905 | New York (NL) 4, Philadephia (AL) 1 |  | 
| 1904 | No Series |  | 
| 1903 | Boston (AL) 5, Pittsburgh (NL) 3 |  |