Kiper: Top 15 Heisman candidates

Plenty of Heisman hopefuls

Harig: Heisman hype is out of hand

Defensive players face uphill Heisman battle

Beano: Heisman deserves the hype

User feedback: Who should win the Heisman Trophy?

Kiper: Top 30 college players for 2001

Mel Kiper's story archive


Thursday, August 23

Five Heisman candidates on defense

My ESPN colleague, Beano Cook, has always said that playing defense alone will not win a player the Heisman Trophy. A defensive player has to do more and display multidimensional skills, as Charles Woodson did as a punt returner and a receiver who caught touchdown passes and made critical receptions for Michigan.

John Henderson
Tennessee's John Henderson is a Heisman long shot.
A dominant cover cornerback won't get as many opportunities to shine because teams will stay away from him. So what Woodson did was remarkable; he entered the 1997 season with everyone knowing he shouldn't be challenged. Yet he used his all-around talent to win the Heisman anyway.

The only way for a defensive player to get serious Heisman consideration would be if he were a cornerback, like Woodson, who also played offense. And players like that don't appear every year. Defensive linemen and linebackers are unlikely to play any other position.

Someone who just plays defense will get Heisman votes only if he is a dominant sack artist, like Hugh Green, who played defensive end for Pitt and was the Heisman runner-up to George Rogers in 1980. That said, following are five defensive players I believe have the best chance to get Heisman votes this season.

John Henderson, DT, Tennessee
Henderson is probably the favorite to win the Lombardi Award as the nation's outstanding lineman. He is a great defensive tackle with size (6-7, 290), explosiveness, ball-location skills and quickness. He has it all. He may be the best defensive lineman the Vols have produced since Reggie White.

Kalimba Edwards, DE, South Carolina
He will be coming off the edge a lot, so he has a chance for lots of sacks and hurries. Edwards can go sideline to sideline and make plays.

Dwight Freeney, DE, Syracuse
Last season Freeney had 4½ sacks against Michael Vick, one of the most mobile QBs to ever play the game. That's all you need to know about Freeney. He had 13 sacks in seven games before missing the final four with a spleen injury. If he can perform the same way consistently, he can gain a reputation early in the year.

Bryan Knight, DE, Pittsburgh
Coming off the edge for the Panthers, he will need tons of sacks. Plus, he's on a bubble team.

Mike Doss, S, Ohio State
He is a Ronnie Lott-type enforcer in the defensive backfield. He will make a lot of plays in the box, but a defensive back would need interceptions and other types of production in his favor, like game-changing tackles or forced fumbles. Doss is capable.

Send this story to a friend | Most sent stories

Copyright ©2000 ESPN Internet Ventures.
Click here for Terms of Use and Privacy Policy applicable to this site.