Max Kellerman

Keyword
BOXING
Champions
Schedule
SPORT SECTIONS
Tuesday, October 23
 
Max: Tszyu's overrated, so go with Zab

By Max Kellerman
Special to ESPN.com

One word explains why Zab Judah will have an easier time than expected with Kostya Tszyu. It's the same word we Yankees fans used to describe the Seattle Mariners at the Stadium on Monday night: overrated. Kostya Tszyu is a top-notch fighter, a solid champion and a wonderful representative for our sport. Every time he opens his mouth outside the ring, he makes me proud to be a boxing fan. But he is not now, nor was he ever, one of the upper echelon pound-for-pound fighters in the world. When Zab beats him let's not hear about how Kostya is not the same fighter he was several years ago, when he was in his ostensible prime.

I remember reading a boxing magazine during Kostya's first year as a pro. There was an article that suggested that Tszyu would one day replace Julio Cesar Chavez as the best pound for pound fighter in the world. Julio Cesar Chavez! When was Chavez ever the best? Pernell Whitaker was Chavez' clear ring superior. But Whitaker had a bad attitude towards the press, hardly ever scored knockouts and whipped the best fighters in the world so easily that he eliminated much of drama that usually accompanies title fights. Chavez, on the other hand, had a million-dollar smile, frequently rallied to come back in brutal action-packed wars, and knocked out most of the men he faced. People in the press wanted Chavez to be the best. They wanted it so much, they simply lied. First to themselves, and then to the boxing public. And so it is to a lesser extent with Kostya Tszyu.

No one ever calls Tszyu the best in the business. There is, however, this idea of Tszyu as a dominant champion, a brutal punching knockout machine. Here is the truth: he is a good but overrated puncher with underrated handspeed. He is a physically strong fighter, a credible belt-holder and solid citizen. And he is now Judah-fodder.

Since the inception of the new Friday Night Fights, I have been touting Zab Judah as an eventual candidate for a slot in the pound-for-pound upper crust. Even a dominant win over Tszyu will not move Judah ahead of Hopkins, Mosley, Jones, Mayweather, Lopez or Barerra. It might, however, put Zab in Felix-Oscar territory.

  • Rahman-Lewis II? I think I am actually going with Rahman by KO again. Sugar Shane-Winky Wright? Shane. Wright is very good, but he is human. Shane Mosley is neither good nor human. He is great and he is not from planet Earth. Spadafora-Manfredy? I think recently on Friday Night Fights I picked Spaddy on points. Might have to change that to Manfredy by knockout. Matter of fact, from now on if you want to know my picks, just read Steve Kim over on Maxboxing.com and whoever he's going with, that's who I'm going with. I don't think the guy has gotten one wrong since Louis-Schmelling I.

  • I have wanted Juan Manuel Marquez on Friday Night Fights for over three years now. This last Friday we finally got him (for a few seconds anyway). He is a tremendous fighter and it is a shame that he has been shut out of the top level fights in and around the featherweight division. Yeah, I'd pick Barrera to beat him, but Morales? I don't know who I'd pick in Marquez vs. Morales. Ditto Hamed. Norwood won a very unpopular decision over Marquez in Juan Manuel's only title shot to date, and while I happen to think that Norwood really did win the fight, I among a small minority who feel that way. (It was also Norwood, and not Marquez, who stunk out the joint that night.) Marquez is like a Vernon Forrest: no matter what you think his chances are in big fights against the best in his division, he deserves the chance to fight those big fights. When Marquez gets his opportunity, win or lose, he is a good bet to give us a memorable fight -- provided his opponent isn't afraid to mix it up.

    Max Kellerman is a studio analyst for ESPN2's Friday Night Fights.





  •  More from ESPN...
    Max Kellerman Archive

     ESPN Tools
    Email story
     
    Most sent
     
    Print story